About the Book:
Western interest in Buddhism has grown enormously in recent years, but because of the scarcity of later Buddhist writings most of the work in the field has dealt with the earlier developments in Buddhism. Also, the available books and articles on Buddhism deal almost exclusively with its religious aspects, and pass over the extensive system of logic that forms an important part of its philosophy as a whole.
This book is coverage of the Mahayana Buddhistic logic of the school of Dignaga (and his follower, expositors, and continuers - especially Dharmakirti). It is in fact the most important work on Buddhist logic ever published. A classic of oriental research, it is founded on a thorough study of original Indian and Tibetan compositions by the great Buddhist logicians. The author was one of the leaders of the St. Petersburg school that did monumental work in the field of Indology during the first quarter of this century.
The first volume is devoted to a history, of Indian logic with Central Asiatic continuations, and then to a detailed expositions of the Dignaga system in terms of theory of knowledge, the sensible world (including causation, sense perception and ultimate reality); the mentally constructed world (judgment, inference, the syllogism, logical fallacies); negation (law of contradiction, universals, dialectic), and the reality of external world. The Second volume is devoted primarily to a translation of Dharmakirti's Nyayabindu, with Dharmottara's commentary. Appendices contain translations from Tibetan logical treatises, Hindu attacks on Buddhist logic, etc.
The author has provided an extremely clear exposition of an important philosophical system that is not well known to the West. The work is all the more, valuable since its is done with an awareness of the history of Western logic and philosophy, well up through Russell and the moderns. Historians of Asian culture, Sanskrit philologists and general philosophers cannot afford to be without it. The general reader with perhaps a basic course in Eastern philosophy will find it highly rewarding.
ContentsVOL. ONE
Abbreviations
Preface
Introduction
- Buddhist Logic what
- The place of Logic in the history of Buddhism
- First period of Buddhist philosophy
- Second period of Buddhist philosophy
- Third period of Buddhist philosophy
- The place of Buddhist Logic in the history of Indian philosophy
- The Materialists
- Jainism
- The Sankhya System
- The Yoga System
- The Vedanta
- The Mimamsa
- The Nyaya-Vaisesika System
- Buddhist Logic before Dignaga
- The life of Dignaga
- The life of Dharmakirti
- The works of Dharmakirti
- The order of the chapters in Pramana-vartika
- The philological school of commentators
- The Cashmere or philosophic school of commentators
- The third or religious school of commentators
- Post-Buddhist Logic and the struggle between Realism and Nominalism in India
- Buddhist Logic in China and Japan
- Buddhist Logic in Tibet and Mongolia
Part I. - Reality and Knowledge (pramanya-vada)
- Scope and aim of Buddhist Logic
- A source of knowledge what
- Cognition and Recognition
- The test of truth
- Realistic and Buddhistic view of experience
- Two realities
- The double character of a source of knowledge
- The limits of cognition. Dogmatism and Criticism
Part II. - The Sensible World
Chapter I. - The theory of Instantaneous Being (ksanika-vada)
- The problem stated
- Reality in kinetic
- Argument from ideality of Time and Space
- Duration and extention are not real
- Argument from direct perception
- Recognition does not prove duration
- Argument from an analysis of the notion of existence
- Argument from an analysis of the notion of non-existence
- Santiraksita's formula
- Change and annihilation
- Motion is discontinuous
- Annihilation certain a priori
- Momentariness deduced from the law of Contradiction
- Is the point-instant a reality? The Differential Calculus
- History of the doctrine of Momentariness
- Some European Parallels
Chapter II. - Causation (pratitya-samutpada)
- Causation as functional dependence
- The formulas of causation
- Causation and Reality identical
- Two kinds of Causality
- Plurality of causes
- Infinity of causes
- Causality and Free Will
- The four meanings of Dependent Origination
- Some European Parallels
Chapter III. - Sense-perception (pratyaksam)
- The definition of sense-perception
- The experiment of Dharmakirti
- Perception and illusion
- The varieties of intuition
- Mental sensation (manasa-praktyaksa)
- The intelligible intuition of the Saint (yogi-pratyaksa)
- Introduction (svasamvedana)
- History of the Indian vies on sense-perception
- Some European Parallels
Chapter IV. - Ultimate reality (paramartha-sat)
- What is ultimately real
- The Particular is the ultimate reality
- Reality is unutterable
- Reality produces a vivid image
- Ultimate Reality is dynamic
- The Monad and the Atom
- Reality is Affirmation
- Objections
- The evolution of the views on Reality
- Some European Parallels
Part III. - The Constructed world
Chapter I. - Judgment
- Transition from pure sensation to conception
- The first steps of the Understanding
- A judgment what
- Judgment and the synthesis in concepts
- Judgment and name giving
- Categories
- Judgment viewed as analysis
- Judgment as objectively valid
- History of the theory of judgment
- Some European Parallels
Chapter II. - Inference
- Judgment and Inference
- The three terms
- The various definitions of inference
- Inferring and Inference
- How far Inference is true knowledge
- The three Aspects of the Reason
- Dhamakirti's tract on relations
- Two lines of dependence
- Analytic and Synthetic judgments
- The final table of Categories
- Are the items of the table mutually exclusive
- Is the Buddhist table of relations exhaustive
- Universal and Necessary Judgments
- The limits of the use of pure Understanding
- Historical sketch of the views of Inference
- Some European Parallels
Chapter III. - Syllogism (pararthanumanam).
- Definition
- The members of syllogism
- Syllogism and Induction
- The figures of Syllogism
- The value of Syllogism
- Historical sketch of Syllogism viewed as inference for others
- European and Buddhist Syllogism
- Definition by Aristotle and by the Buddhists
- Aristotle's Syllogism from Example
- Inference and Induction
- the Buddhist syllogism contains two propositions
- Contraposition
- Figures
- The Causal and Hypothetical Syllogism
- Summary
Chapter IV. - Logical Fallacies
- Classification
- Fallacy against Reality (asiddha-hetv-abhasa)
- Fallacy of a Contrary Reason
- fallacy of an Uncertain Reason
- The Antinomical Fallacy
- Dharmakirti's additions
- History
- Manuals of Dialecties
- The refutative syllogism of the Madhyamikas
- The Vaisesika system influenced by the Buddhists
- The Nyaya system influenced by Diguaga
- European Parallels
Part IV. - Negation
Chapter I. - The negative judgment
- The essence of Negation
- Negation is an Inference
- The figures of the Negative Syllogism. The figure of Simple Negation
- The ten remaining figures
- Importance of Negation
- Contradiction and Causality only in the Empirical Sphere
- Negation of supersensuous objects
- Indian developments
- European Parallels:
- Sigwart's theory
- Denied copula and Negative Predicate
- Judgment and Re-judgment
Chapter II. - The Law of Contradiction.
- The origin of Contradiction
- Logical Contradiction
- Dynamical opposition
- Law of Otherness
- Different formulations of the Laws of Contradiction and Otherness
- Other Indian schools on Contradiction
- Some European Parallels
- The Law of Excluded Middle
- The Law of Double Negation
- The Law of Identity
- Two European Logics
- Heracleitus
- Causation and Identity in the fragments of Heracleitus
- The Eleatic Law of Contradiction
- Plato
- Kant and Sigwart
- The Aristotelian formula of Contradiction and Dharmakirti's theory of Relations
Chapter III. - Universals
- The static Universality of Things replaced by similarity of action
- History of the problem of Universals
- Some European Parallels
Chapter IV. - Dialectic
- Dignaga's Theory of Names
- Jinendrabuddhi on the Theory of the Negative Meaning of Names
- All names are negative
- The origin of Universals
- Controversy with the Realist
- The experience of individuals becomes the agreed experience of the Human Mind
- Conclusion
- Santiraksita and Kamalasila on the negative meaning of words
- Historical sketch of the development of the Buddhist Dialectical Method
- European Parallels
Kant and Hegel
- J.S. Mill and A. Bain
- Sigwart
- Affirmation what
- Ulrici and Lotze
Part V. - Reality of the External World
- What is Real
- What is External
- The three worlds
- Critical Realism
- Ultimate Monism
- Idealism
- Dignaga's tract on the Unreality of the External World
- Dharmakirti's tract on the Repudiation of Solipsism
- History of the problem of the Reality of the External World
- Some European Parallels
- Indo-European Symposion on the Reality of the External World
Conclusion
Indices
Appendix
Addenda
VOL. TWO
Contents
Preface
A Short treatise of Logic (Nyaya-bindu) by Dharmakirti with its commentary (Nyaya-bindu-tika) by Dharmottara translated from the sanscrit text edited in the Bibliotheka Buddhica
- Perception
- Inference
- Syllogism
Appendices
- Vacaspatimisra on the Buddhist Theory of Perception
- Vacaspatimisra on the Buddhist Theory of a radical distinction between sensation and conception (pramana-vyavastha versus pramana-samplaya)
- The theory of mental sensation (manasa-pratyaksa)
- Vasubandhu, Vinitadeva, Vacaspatimisra, Udayana, Dignaga and Jinendrabuddhi on the act and the content of knowledge, on the coordination (sarupya) of percepts with their objects and on our knowledge of the external world
- Vacaspatimisra on Buddhist Nominalism (apohavada)
- Corrections to the texts of the Nyayabindu, Nyaya-bindu-tika and Nyaya-bindu-tika-Tippani printed in the Bibliotheka Buddhica
Indices
- Proper names
- Schools
- Sanscrit works
- Sanscrit words and expressions
Free Shipping. Delivered by
to all international destinations within 3 to 5 days, fully insured.