Subscribe for Newsletters and Discounts
Be the first to receive our thoughtfully written
religious articles and product discounts.
Your interests (Optional)
This will help us make recommendations and send discounts and sale information at times.
By registering, you may receive account related information, our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
.
By subscribing, you will receive our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. All emails will be sent by Exotic India using the email address info@exoticindia.com.

Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
|6
Your Cart (0)
Share our website with your friends.
Email this page to a friend
Books > Buddhist > Caste and Buddhist Philosophy (Continuity of Some Buddhist Arguments Against the Realist Interpretation of Social Denominations)
Displaying 255 of 1682         Previous  |  NextSubscribe to our newsletter and discounts
Caste and Buddhist Philosophy (Continuity of Some Buddhist Arguments Against the Realist Interpretation of Social Denominations)
Caste and Buddhist Philosophy (Continuity of Some Buddhist Arguments Against the Realist Interpretation of Social Denominations)
Description
About the Book

From the sixth to the eighth century CE, the Buddhist Philosopher paid considerable attention to the issue of the caste-classes. Far from seeking to reform the non-buddhist social environment, they endeavoured to undermine theoretical attempts at “naturalizing” the social statuses, especially Kumarila’s doctrine of the perceptibility of jati. Significant parts of their critique is strongly indebted to earlier, mainly caonical arguments shaped in order to neutralize the Brhahmins’ pride in caste. But closer scrutiny also reveals the innovations that were made possible by the renewal of Buddhist semantics around the so-called apoha (“exclusion”) theory. Eltschinger’s study presents the gist of the early Buddhist arguments, the modalities of their appropriation by the later philosophers as well as the new developments induced by the epistemologists.

 

About the Author

Vincent Eltschinger has studied and taught at the University of Lausanne and is now a research fellow at the Austrian Academy of Sciences. His many books and articles bear on the religious and apologetic dimensions of late Indian Buddhist philosophy as well as on the religion philosophical interaction between Buddhism and Brhamanical orthodoxy.

 

Preface

The French original of this book was published in 2000 as I was still a doctoral student at the University of Lausanne. Since then, I have never turned back to the issue of the Buddhist treatment of the caste-classes, and, t the best of my knowledge, no substantial study has been dedicatedto this topic in the meantime. While revising Raynald prevereau’s excellent translation, I became increasingly aware of the many defect of the original study. Among the most congenial and hence irredeemable ones, let me mention a lack of sociohistorical contexualization, the teleological nature of the presentation, and my disregard for issues of canonicity and canonization. Since then, my reading scholars like R.M. Davidson, A. Sanderson and G. Schopen, to name but a few, has convinced me that such a purely “Internalist”. Way of dealing with textual sources should belong to the past. Fortunately, this textual sources should belong to the opportunity to improve my reading of certain passages, to add a few source materials and to update bibliographical references. Moreover, following a recent study by H. Krasser (2011). I am now inclined to ascribe earlier dates to Dharmakirti ( a junior contemporary of Dharmapala and a senior contemporary of Bhaviveka, some time during the sixth century). I have tried my best in order to accommodate my argument with this new chronology. Most sincere thanks are due to Alexander von Rospatt and Ernst Steinkellner ( as ever!) for their readiness to publish this monograph in the Buddhist Tradition series, and to the elisabet de Boer fund for Financing its English translation. Finally Raynald Prevereau deserves my heartfelt gratitude for all he has been doing, from the first version of his translation to the tiresome incorporation of my final corrections

 

Foreword

The rigorous denial by the Buddha and his followers of the Brahmanic idea of castes as a natural fact is a well-known detail in the long history of the study of India's social structures and their ideological background. From early canonical texts to later philosophical literature, this denial is regularly attested. The early Buddhist positions and refutations have been extensively documented, beginning with the seminal study by Richard Fick (German: Kiel 1897, English: Varanasi 1972). However, with the exception of P. L. Barua, who presents early arguments against caste as a fact of nature, the study of these positions has focussed on the social and historical data they may provide. Until now, the later systematic and post-systematic developments in Buddhist philosophical traditions have not been taken into consideration, It is these that are the focus of this volume.

The author offers a detailed analysis of the arguments against the Brahmanic "naturalization of caste," as propounded by Dharmakirti (ca. 600 CE) and his successors up to Prajfiakaragupta (ca. 800 CE), and in the process pays close attention to their historical context as exemplified by the writings of Aryadeva, Vasubandhu, Dharrnapala, and Candrakirti. The first section provides a survey of the canonical material in relevant Pali Suttas and subsequent Avadana and [ataka literature. This introduces the reader to the sources for the arguments concerning caste, both against caste as a natural fact and for caste as an outcome of social conventions. Arguing from biological and genealogical standpoints, and pointing to the instability of brahmanity as a social category, these early materials reject that "brahmanity" is a natural given. While it is evident that one objective of these early sources was to proselytize, the attempts to systematize the Buddha's teachings in the different scholastic Abhidharmas were in the main intent on doctrinal clarifications within the various Buddhist groups. The question whether castes are a natural given rather than a social construct was only of marginal interest. In the sixth and seventh centuries, however, with Dharmapala and Dharrnakirti and his contemporary Candrakirti. Buddhist scholasticism increasingly confronted non-Buddhist traditions. As a result Buddhist polemics against the innateness of caste were provided with a more rigorous philosophical foundation. Dharmakirtf in particular "was the first to move the polemic to the level of epistemology and ontology" (p. 59). This transformed the traditional reasoning into strict arguments formed in terms of the standards Dharmakirti had shaped in his ontology, epistemology and logic .

The main part of the book presents the final stage in the evolution of polemics against the "naturalization" of caste in the sense of "any attempt to include caste among the things that do not depend or proceed exclusively from human thought and arbitrary conventions, i.e., to consider caste as agreeing with nature' and not merely with people's social and linguistic habits" (p. xix). This section focuses on the arguments of Dharrnakirti. These are set into the context of pre- and post-Dharrnakirtian Buddhist voices, including Vasubandhu, Aryadeva, Candrakirti, Dharrnapala, Dharmakirti's commentators Sakyabuddhi, Kamakagomin and Prajfiakaragupta, as well as Santara~ita and Kamalasila, Representing the Brahmanic opposition, the Mimamsaka Kumarila was in all likelihood Dharmakirti's main opponent for his arguments concerning the perceptibility of distinct classes. Internally, Dharmakirti's arguments are found in the context of his explanations concerning nominalistic ontology and linguistic theory. This is because he does not separate the problem of caste from that of universals in general.

Throughout the volume, these steps are carefully attested with clear translations and textual documentation. Wrapping up the results of his study, the author's conclusions draw a succinct picture of the Buddhist position on caste, gained through the broader understanding of the historical and social facts and changes that took place during the periods these documents were created. Moreover, in considering the validity of his study for present-day India, the author ventures the opinion that "the vast majority of points raised in the Buddhist argumentations remain a burning question, even today"

 

Contents

 

  Editors' foreword vii
  Preface to the English translation xi
  Preface to the French original. xiii
Chapter 1 - Canonical antecedents  
1.1 Outline of a Buddhist explanation. 1
1.2 Biological arguments: animal and plant species 17
1.3 Genealogical arguments. 24
1.4 Unstable brahmanity. 49
Chapter 2 - Dharrnakirti and his successors  
2.1 Before and around Dharmakirti 57
2.1.1 Introduction. 57
2.1.1.1 Vasubandhu against the homogeneous character (sabhagata/nikayasabhaga) 59
2.1.1.2 Aryadeva and Candrakirti 71
2.1.1.3 Dharrnapala and the Brahmanic usurpation 81
2.1.2 Dharmakirti and the reformulation of the polemic. 84
2.1.2.1 Internal explanation: the theory of exclusion (apoha). 85
2.2 Context and problematic of Dharmakirti's discussion 94
2.3 Dharmakirti against the class jati 103
2.3.1 Immediate context 103
2.3.2 The argument 107
2.3.3 Explanation 112
2.3.4 Conclusion 115
2.4 On the perceptibility of class jati 116
2.4.1 Kumarila 116
2.4.2 Dharrnakirti. 123
2.4.3 Prajfiakaragupta 127
2.5 Post-Dharrnakirtian developments of the argumentation 137
2.5.1 Biological and genealogical arguments 138
2.5.2 The "true Brahmins": substitution of the paradigm ofbrahmanity 140
2.5.3 Activity (kriya) and sacraments (samaskara) 143
2.5.4 Lineage (gotra) and genealogy 146
2.5.5 Superior capacities of Brahmins 153
2.5.6 Conclusions 154
Chapter 3 - Conclusions 157
  Bibliography and abbreviations 177
  Indices 195
     

Sample Pages

















Caste and Buddhist Philosophy (Continuity of Some Buddhist Arguments Against the Realist Interpretation of Social Denominations)

Item Code:
NAE749
Cover:
Hardcover
Edition:
2015
ISBN:
9788120835597
Language:
English
Size:
9.0 inch X 6.0 inch
Pages:
261
Other Details:
Weight of the Book: 500 gms
Price:
$30.00   Shipping Free
Add to Wishlist
Send as e-card
Send as free online greeting card
Caste and Buddhist Philosophy (Continuity of Some Buddhist Arguments Against the Realist Interpretation of Social Denominations)

Verify the characters on the left

From:
Edit     
You will be informed as and when your card is viewed. Please note that your card will be active in the system for 30 days.

Viewed 3031 times since 2nd Nov, 2016
About the Book

From the sixth to the eighth century CE, the Buddhist Philosopher paid considerable attention to the issue of the caste-classes. Far from seeking to reform the non-buddhist social environment, they endeavoured to undermine theoretical attempts at “naturalizing” the social statuses, especially Kumarila’s doctrine of the perceptibility of jati. Significant parts of their critique is strongly indebted to earlier, mainly caonical arguments shaped in order to neutralize the Brhahmins’ pride in caste. But closer scrutiny also reveals the innovations that were made possible by the renewal of Buddhist semantics around the so-called apoha (“exclusion”) theory. Eltschinger’s study presents the gist of the early Buddhist arguments, the modalities of their appropriation by the later philosophers as well as the new developments induced by the epistemologists.

 

About the Author

Vincent Eltschinger has studied and taught at the University of Lausanne and is now a research fellow at the Austrian Academy of Sciences. His many books and articles bear on the religious and apologetic dimensions of late Indian Buddhist philosophy as well as on the religion philosophical interaction between Buddhism and Brhamanical orthodoxy.

 

Preface

The French original of this book was published in 2000 as I was still a doctoral student at the University of Lausanne. Since then, I have never turned back to the issue of the Buddhist treatment of the caste-classes, and, t the best of my knowledge, no substantial study has been dedicatedto this topic in the meantime. While revising Raynald prevereau’s excellent translation, I became increasingly aware of the many defect of the original study. Among the most congenial and hence irredeemable ones, let me mention a lack of sociohistorical contexualization, the teleological nature of the presentation, and my disregard for issues of canonicity and canonization. Since then, my reading scholars like R.M. Davidson, A. Sanderson and G. Schopen, to name but a few, has convinced me that such a purely “Internalist”. Way of dealing with textual sources should belong to the past. Fortunately, this textual sources should belong to the opportunity to improve my reading of certain passages, to add a few source materials and to update bibliographical references. Moreover, following a recent study by H. Krasser (2011). I am now inclined to ascribe earlier dates to Dharmakirti ( a junior contemporary of Dharmapala and a senior contemporary of Bhaviveka, some time during the sixth century). I have tried my best in order to accommodate my argument with this new chronology. Most sincere thanks are due to Alexander von Rospatt and Ernst Steinkellner ( as ever!) for their readiness to publish this monograph in the Buddhist Tradition series, and to the elisabet de Boer fund for Financing its English translation. Finally Raynald Prevereau deserves my heartfelt gratitude for all he has been doing, from the first version of his translation to the tiresome incorporation of my final corrections

 

Foreword

The rigorous denial by the Buddha and his followers of the Brahmanic idea of castes as a natural fact is a well-known detail in the long history of the study of India's social structures and their ideological background. From early canonical texts to later philosophical literature, this denial is regularly attested. The early Buddhist positions and refutations have been extensively documented, beginning with the seminal study by Richard Fick (German: Kiel 1897, English: Varanasi 1972). However, with the exception of P. L. Barua, who presents early arguments against caste as a fact of nature, the study of these positions has focussed on the social and historical data they may provide. Until now, the later systematic and post-systematic developments in Buddhist philosophical traditions have not been taken into consideration, It is these that are the focus of this volume.

The author offers a detailed analysis of the arguments against the Brahmanic "naturalization of caste," as propounded by Dharmakirti (ca. 600 CE) and his successors up to Prajfiakaragupta (ca. 800 CE), and in the process pays close attention to their historical context as exemplified by the writings of Aryadeva, Vasubandhu, Dharrnapala, and Candrakirti. The first section provides a survey of the canonical material in relevant Pali Suttas and subsequent Avadana and [ataka literature. This introduces the reader to the sources for the arguments concerning caste, both against caste as a natural fact and for caste as an outcome of social conventions. Arguing from biological and genealogical standpoints, and pointing to the instability of brahmanity as a social category, these early materials reject that "brahmanity" is a natural given. While it is evident that one objective of these early sources was to proselytize, the attempts to systematize the Buddha's teachings in the different scholastic Abhidharmas were in the main intent on doctrinal clarifications within the various Buddhist groups. The question whether castes are a natural given rather than a social construct was only of marginal interest. In the sixth and seventh centuries, however, with Dharmapala and Dharrnakirti and his contemporary Candrakirti. Buddhist scholasticism increasingly confronted non-Buddhist traditions. As a result Buddhist polemics against the innateness of caste were provided with a more rigorous philosophical foundation. Dharmakirtf in particular "was the first to move the polemic to the level of epistemology and ontology" (p. 59). This transformed the traditional reasoning into strict arguments formed in terms of the standards Dharmakirti had shaped in his ontology, epistemology and logic .

The main part of the book presents the final stage in the evolution of polemics against the "naturalization" of caste in the sense of "any attempt to include caste among the things that do not depend or proceed exclusively from human thought and arbitrary conventions, i.e., to consider caste as agreeing with nature' and not merely with people's social and linguistic habits" (p. xix). This section focuses on the arguments of Dharrnakirti. These are set into the context of pre- and post-Dharrnakirtian Buddhist voices, including Vasubandhu, Aryadeva, Candrakirti, Dharrnapala, Dharmakirti's commentators Sakyabuddhi, Kamakagomin and Prajfiakaragupta, as well as Santara~ita and Kamalasila, Representing the Brahmanic opposition, the Mimamsaka Kumarila was in all likelihood Dharmakirti's main opponent for his arguments concerning the perceptibility of distinct classes. Internally, Dharmakirti's arguments are found in the context of his explanations concerning nominalistic ontology and linguistic theory. This is because he does not separate the problem of caste from that of universals in general.

Throughout the volume, these steps are carefully attested with clear translations and textual documentation. Wrapping up the results of his study, the author's conclusions draw a succinct picture of the Buddhist position on caste, gained through the broader understanding of the historical and social facts and changes that took place during the periods these documents were created. Moreover, in considering the validity of his study for present-day India, the author ventures the opinion that "the vast majority of points raised in the Buddhist argumentations remain a burning question, even today"

 

Contents

 

  Editors' foreword vii
  Preface to the English translation xi
  Preface to the French original. xiii
Chapter 1 - Canonical antecedents  
1.1 Outline of a Buddhist explanation. 1
1.2 Biological arguments: animal and plant species 17
1.3 Genealogical arguments. 24
1.4 Unstable brahmanity. 49
Chapter 2 - Dharrnakirti and his successors  
2.1 Before and around Dharmakirti 57
2.1.1 Introduction. 57
2.1.1.1 Vasubandhu against the homogeneous character (sabhagata/nikayasabhaga) 59
2.1.1.2 Aryadeva and Candrakirti 71
2.1.1.3 Dharrnapala and the Brahmanic usurpation 81
2.1.2 Dharmakirti and the reformulation of the polemic. 84
2.1.2.1 Internal explanation: the theory of exclusion (apoha). 85
2.2 Context and problematic of Dharmakirti's discussion 94
2.3 Dharmakirti against the class jati 103
2.3.1 Immediate context 103
2.3.2 The argument 107
2.3.3 Explanation 112
2.3.4 Conclusion 115
2.4 On the perceptibility of class jati 116
2.4.1 Kumarila 116
2.4.2 Dharrnakirti. 123
2.4.3 Prajfiakaragupta 127
2.5 Post-Dharrnakirtian developments of the argumentation 137
2.5.1 Biological and genealogical arguments 138
2.5.2 The "true Brahmins": substitution of the paradigm ofbrahmanity 140
2.5.3 Activity (kriya) and sacraments (samaskara) 143
2.5.4 Lineage (gotra) and genealogy 146
2.5.5 Superior capacities of Brahmins 153
2.5.6 Conclusions 154
Chapter 3 - Conclusions 157
  Bibliography and abbreviations 177
  Indices 195
     

Sample Pages

















Post a Comment
 
Post Review
Post a Query
For privacy concerns, please view our Privacy Policy

Related Items

Nepalese Casted Vessels, Decanters and Bowls
Item Code: IDJ053
$20.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Newar Society (City, Village and Periphery)
by Gerard Toffin
Paperback (Edition: 2008)
Himal Books, Nepal
Item Code: NAM634
$40.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Life in Ancient India (As Depicted in The Digha-Nikaya): An Old Book
by Dr. Chittaranjan Patra
Hardcover (Edition: 1996)
Punthi Pustak
Item Code: NAJ357
$27.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Newars (An Ethno-Sociological Study of a Himalayan Community)
by Gopal Singh Nepali
Hardcover (Edition: 2015)
Mandala Book Point, Nepal
Item Code: NAM338
$40.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Cult of Kumari Virgin Worship in Nepal
by Michael Allen
Paperback (Edition: 1996)
Mandala Book Point, Nepal
Item Code: NAJ676
$35.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Ethnicity, Inequality, and Politics in Nepal
Item Code: NAM351
$25.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
People of Nepal
by Dor Bahadur Bista
Paperback (Edition: 2015)
Ratna Pustak Bhandar, Nepal
Item Code: NAM643
$45.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Rajbanshis of Nepal
by Rajesh Gautam
Hardcover (Edition: 2005)
Adroit Publishers, Delhi
Item Code: NAM644
$25.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Origin and Nature of Ancient Indian Buddhism
Item Code: IHJ091
$35.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Buddhism and Sarvodaya (Sri Lankan Experience)
by A.T. Ariyaratne
Hardcover (Edition: 1996)
Sri Satguru Publications
Item Code: NAC110
$25.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now

Testimonials

The Bhairava painting I ordered by Sri Kailash Raj is excellent. I have been purchasing from Exotic India for well over a decade and am always beyond delighted with my extraordinary purchases and customer service. Thank you.
Marc, UK
I have been buying from Exotic India for years and am always pleased and excited to receive my packages. Thanks for the quality products.
Delia, USA
As ever, brilliant price and service.
Howard, UK.
The best and fastest service worldwide - I am in Australia and I put in a big order of books (14 items) on a Wednesday; it was sent on Friday and arrived at my doorstep early on Monday morning - amazing! All very securely packed in a very strong cardboard box. I have bought several times from Exotic India and the service is always exceptionally good. THANK YOU and NAMASTE!
Charles (Rudra)
I just wanted to say that this is I think my 3rd (big) order from you, and the last two times I received immaculate service, the books arrived well and it has been a very pleasant experience. Just wanted to say thanks for your efficient service.
Shantala, Belgium
Thank you so much EXOTIC INDIA for the wonderfull packaging!! I received my order today and it was gift wrapped with so much love and taste in a beautiful golden gift wrap and everything was neat and beautifully packed. Also my order came very fast... i am impressed! Besides selling fantastic items, you provide an exceptional customer service and i will surely purchase again from you! I am very glad and happy :) Thank you, Salma
Salma, Canada.
Artwork received today. Very pleased both with the product quality and speed of delivery. Many thanks for your help.
Carl, UK.
I wanted to let you know how happy we are with our framed pieces of Shree Durga and Shree Kali. Thank you and thank your framers for us. By the way, this month we offered a Puja and Yagna to the Ardhanarishwara murti we purchased from you last November. The Brahmin priest, Shree Vivek Godbol, who was visiting LA preformed the rites. He really loved our murti and thought it very paka. I am so happy to have found your site , it is very paka and trustworthy. Plus such great packing and quick shipping. Thanks for your service Vipin, it is a pleasure.
Gina, USA
My marble statue of Durga arrived today in perfect condition, it's such a beautiful statue. Thanks again for giving me a discount on it, I'm always very pleased with the items I order from you. You always have the best quality items.
Charles, Tennessee
Jay Shree Krishna Shrimud Bhagavatam Mahapurana in Sanskrat Parayana is very very thankful to you we are so gratefully to your seva
Mrs. Darbar, UK.
TRUSTe
Language:
Currency:
All rights reserved. Copyright 2017 © Exotic India