Subscribe for Newsletters and Discounts
Be the first to receive our thoughtfully written
religious articles and product discounts.
Your interests (Optional)
This will help us make recommendations and send discounts and sale information at times.
By registering, you may receive account related information, our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
.
By subscribing, you will receive our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. All emails will be sent by Exotic India using the email address info@exoticindia.com.

Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
|6
Your Cart (0)
Share our website with your friends.
Email this page to a friend
Books > Philosophy > Jadavpur Journal of Philosophy: Volume 23 Number 1(English) 2013-14
Displaying 768 of 2804         Previous  |  NextSubscribe to our newsletter and discounts
Jadavpur Journal of Philosophy: Volume 23 Number 1(English) 2013-14
Jadavpur Journal of Philosophy: Volume 23 Number 1(English) 2013-14
Description
About The Book

Jadavpur Journal of Philosophy is a refereed, bi-issue journal, in English (No.1) and Bengali (No.2) published annually by the Department of Philosophy, Jadavpur University, Kolkata, India. The journal volume in Bengali is titled Darsan Biksa. The journal is devoted to the publication of original scholarly papers in any branch of philosophy. Its objective is to encourage contributions from scholars, dealing with specific philosophical problems connected with their respective fields of specialization.

Introduction

Dispositional terms like solubility, fragility, malleability and conductivity are frequently used in understanding the physical world. These dispositional terms, particularly in the discourse of science, appear to be just a manner of speaking and are mere "abstractions" to represent the behaviour of the things in certain circumstances and nothing more. However, in the way they are used, it also gives a sense that they are real things in the world. Are these dispositions actual and real properties or powers that reside in the things but do not manifest themselves? "Yes, they are" is a position taken by philosophers who are realists about dispositions. As against this the anti-realists, notably David Hume, Gilbert Ryle and Michael Dummett, contend that dispositional terms just represent or describe the behaviour of things in certain circumstances. Mellor (1974) attempts to raise the "status of dispositions" and considers them to be "real" properties. With scientific essentialism. gaining importance in recent years essentialists like Brian Ellis (2001) and Alexander Bird (2007) grant the status of properties to dispositions. Further, Molnar (2006), Heil (2005) and Martin (1994) treat dispositions as powers or capacities that a thing can possess. The realists come up with different arguments in favour of their position and attempt to establish that dispositions are real properties by refuting the anti-realist claims and accounts of dispositions. Much of the discussions and arguments in defence of such a position and refutation of anti-realist position are based on some assumptions that do not seem to be warranted. They also invoke certain interesting ideas that make the arguments look persuasive. In this paper I take up what appears to be strong arguments made in defence of the realist position by Mumford (1998), Molnar (2006) and Martin (1994).1 They make use of some interesting ideas and imagined cases that make their arguments look sound. The purpose of this paper is to critically discuss some of their arguments in the subsequent sections, particularly to get into some of the details of these underlying ideas, and attempt to bring certain issues to the fore that appear to have been glossed over in the use of these ideas. Thus, there is a need to recognize that the arguments presented by the realists in favour of the position that dispositions is real and their refutation of the anti- realist position is less than persuasive.

In the second section I begin with Mumford's discussion of dispositions as properties. Here I attempt to show how the ideas of causal relevance, explanation and functional characterization are brought together in a question begging way to show that dispositions are properties. However, such explanations invoking dispositions are generally not accepted as genuine explanations but instead are said to be virtus dormitiva explanations. If this is so, then it implies that Mumford's argument stands to lose much of its strength. Therefore, Mumford downplays the charge of virtus dormitiva explanation. I attempt to show how such a charge of virtus dormitiva type of explanation has been downplayed by Mumford. If the charge of the virtus dormitiva is one that cannot be brushed aside by downplaying it then one cannot talk of dispositions as the realists do, i.e. as actual unmanifest properties possessed by a thing that it can gain or lose in time, as any other property. As dispositions do not actually manifest themselves, it is explained or understood in terms of the conditional.

The third section discusses the unmanifest and actual nature of dispositions, examines Martin's arguments refuting the reductive analysis of dispositions in terms of strict conditionals and attempts to reveal the circularity inherent in Molnar's argument on the actuality of dispositions. Dispositions are generally understood in terms of conditionals and such conditionals are nothing but descriptions of what happens in certain circumstances. If this is so, then again, dispositions cannot be viewed as properties. Mumford, therefore, develops the idea of functional characterization by means of which he develops an interesting conceptual connection between dispositions and conditionals. The reason why he argues for such a conceptual connection is that he wants to refute the idea that dispositions are nothing more than descriptions of what happens in certain circumstances and thereby establish that dispositions have property status.

In the fourth section I present Mumford's idea of functional characterization and also allude to the similar views of Molnar. I argue that the very idea of functional characterization does not appear to be relevant in the understanding of dispositions.

Contents

1The Property Status of Dispositions: Is the Position Defensible?1
S.K. ARUN MURTHI
2Sankari Prasad Banerjee on Freedom: Some Reflection27
TIRTHANATH BANDYOPADHYAY
3Symbols and Change39
D. BALAGANAPATHI
4Genesis of the Superman49
UMA DHAR
5In the Shadow of Death: Beyond Heidegger's Subjectivity61
SANJIT CHAKRABORTY
6Are Persons Substances?: A Critique of Locke's Theory of Personal Identity73
SHEWLI DUTTA
7Kripkean Theory of Reference: A Cognitive Way89
ROSHAN PRA VEEN XALXO
8Anselm's Definition of God103
SANJIB DEB
9Early Life of Scientific Theories: A Model-based Analysis127
SREEKUMAR JAYADEVAN
10Discerning Pervasive Patterns in Indian and Western Aesthetics: With Special Reference to Anandavardhana, Abhinavagupta and Immanuel Kant141
AHINPUNYA MITRA
Book Review167
List of Contributors171

Jadavpur Journal of Philosophy: Volume 23 Number 1(English) 2013-14

Item Code:
NAH553
Cover:
Paperback
Edition:
2014
ISBN:
09756833
Language:
English
Size:
9.8 inch x 6.5 inch
Pages:
176
Other Details:
Weight of the Book: 320 gms
Price:
$21.00
Discounted:
$16.80   Shipping Free
You Save:
$4.20 (20%)
Add to Wishlist
Send as e-card
Send as free online greeting card
Jadavpur Journal of Philosophy: Volume 23 Number 1(English) 2013-14

Verify the characters on the left

From:
Edit     
You will be informed as and when your card is viewed. Please note that your card will be active in the system for 30 days.

Viewed 1650 times since 13th Jun, 2016
About The Book

Jadavpur Journal of Philosophy is a refereed, bi-issue journal, in English (No.1) and Bengali (No.2) published annually by the Department of Philosophy, Jadavpur University, Kolkata, India. The journal volume in Bengali is titled Darsan Biksa. The journal is devoted to the publication of original scholarly papers in any branch of philosophy. Its objective is to encourage contributions from scholars, dealing with specific philosophical problems connected with their respective fields of specialization.

Introduction

Dispositional terms like solubility, fragility, malleability and conductivity are frequently used in understanding the physical world. These dispositional terms, particularly in the discourse of science, appear to be just a manner of speaking and are mere "abstractions" to represent the behaviour of the things in certain circumstances and nothing more. However, in the way they are used, it also gives a sense that they are real things in the world. Are these dispositions actual and real properties or powers that reside in the things but do not manifest themselves? "Yes, they are" is a position taken by philosophers who are realists about dispositions. As against this the anti-realists, notably David Hume, Gilbert Ryle and Michael Dummett, contend that dispositional terms just represent or describe the behaviour of things in certain circumstances. Mellor (1974) attempts to raise the "status of dispositions" and considers them to be "real" properties. With scientific essentialism. gaining importance in recent years essentialists like Brian Ellis (2001) and Alexander Bird (2007) grant the status of properties to dispositions. Further, Molnar (2006), Heil (2005) and Martin (1994) treat dispositions as powers or capacities that a thing can possess. The realists come up with different arguments in favour of their position and attempt to establish that dispositions are real properties by refuting the anti-realist claims and accounts of dispositions. Much of the discussions and arguments in defence of such a position and refutation of anti-realist position are based on some assumptions that do not seem to be warranted. They also invoke certain interesting ideas that make the arguments look persuasive. In this paper I take up what appears to be strong arguments made in defence of the realist position by Mumford (1998), Molnar (2006) and Martin (1994).1 They make use of some interesting ideas and imagined cases that make their arguments look sound. The purpose of this paper is to critically discuss some of their arguments in the subsequent sections, particularly to get into some of the details of these underlying ideas, and attempt to bring certain issues to the fore that appear to have been glossed over in the use of these ideas. Thus, there is a need to recognize that the arguments presented by the realists in favour of the position that dispositions is real and their refutation of the anti- realist position is less than persuasive.

In the second section I begin with Mumford's discussion of dispositions as properties. Here I attempt to show how the ideas of causal relevance, explanation and functional characterization are brought together in a question begging way to show that dispositions are properties. However, such explanations invoking dispositions are generally not accepted as genuine explanations but instead are said to be virtus dormitiva explanations. If this is so, then it implies that Mumford's argument stands to lose much of its strength. Therefore, Mumford downplays the charge of virtus dormitiva explanation. I attempt to show how such a charge of virtus dormitiva type of explanation has been downplayed by Mumford. If the charge of the virtus dormitiva is one that cannot be brushed aside by downplaying it then one cannot talk of dispositions as the realists do, i.e. as actual unmanifest properties possessed by a thing that it can gain or lose in time, as any other property. As dispositions do not actually manifest themselves, it is explained or understood in terms of the conditional.

The third section discusses the unmanifest and actual nature of dispositions, examines Martin's arguments refuting the reductive analysis of dispositions in terms of strict conditionals and attempts to reveal the circularity inherent in Molnar's argument on the actuality of dispositions. Dispositions are generally understood in terms of conditionals and such conditionals are nothing but descriptions of what happens in certain circumstances. If this is so, then again, dispositions cannot be viewed as properties. Mumford, therefore, develops the idea of functional characterization by means of which he develops an interesting conceptual connection between dispositions and conditionals. The reason why he argues for such a conceptual connection is that he wants to refute the idea that dispositions are nothing more than descriptions of what happens in certain circumstances and thereby establish that dispositions have property status.

In the fourth section I present Mumford's idea of functional characterization and also allude to the similar views of Molnar. I argue that the very idea of functional characterization does not appear to be relevant in the understanding of dispositions.

Contents

1The Property Status of Dispositions: Is the Position Defensible?1
S.K. ARUN MURTHI
2Sankari Prasad Banerjee on Freedom: Some Reflection27
TIRTHANATH BANDYOPADHYAY
3Symbols and Change39
D. BALAGANAPATHI
4Genesis of the Superman49
UMA DHAR
5In the Shadow of Death: Beyond Heidegger's Subjectivity61
SANJIT CHAKRABORTY
6Are Persons Substances?: A Critique of Locke's Theory of Personal Identity73
SHEWLI DUTTA
7Kripkean Theory of Reference: A Cognitive Way89
ROSHAN PRA VEEN XALXO
8Anselm's Definition of God103
SANJIB DEB
9Early Life of Scientific Theories: A Model-based Analysis127
SREEKUMAR JAYADEVAN
10Discerning Pervasive Patterns in Indian and Western Aesthetics: With Special Reference to Anandavardhana, Abhinavagupta and Immanuel Kant141
AHINPUNYA MITRA
Book Review167
List of Contributors171
Post a Comment
 
Post Review
Post a Query
For privacy concerns, please view our Privacy Policy

Related Items

Jadavpur Journal of Philosophy: Volume 25 Number 1(English) 2015-16
Item Code: NAM949
$25.00$20.00
You save: $5.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Jadavpur Journal of Philosophy
Item Code: NAK756
$22.00$17.60
You save: $4.40 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Krishnamurti's Journal
by J. Krishnamurti
Paperback (Edition: 2003)
Krishnamurti Foundation India.
Item Code: IDD601
$16.50$13.20
You save: $3.30 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
THE PHILOSOPHY OF LIFE: Facets of Recent Indian Philosophy
Item Code: IDH021
$35.00$28.00
You save: $7.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Problems of Indian Philosophy (FACETS OF RECENT INDIAN 

PHILOSOPHY)
Item Code: IDH010
$30.00$24.00
You save: $6.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Interpreting Across Boundaries: New Essays in Comparative Philosophy
Item Code: IDE381
$19.50$15.60
You save: $3.90 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Perspectives on Indian History, Historiography and Philosophy of History
by G. P. Singh
Hardcover (Edition: 2009)
D. K. Printworld Pvt. Ltd.
Item Code: NAD219
$30.00$24.00
You save: $6.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Language Being and Cognition (Philosophy of Language and Analysis : Contemporary Perspective)
by Devendra Nath Tiwari
Hardcover (Edition: 2014)
Madhav Vidya Bhavan
Item Code: NAL141
$70.00$56.00
You save: $14.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Development of Nyaya Philosophy and Its Social Context
Item Code: NAD326
$95.00$76.00
You save: $19.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Analysis and Philosophy (An Old and Rare Book)
Item Code: NAM014
$20.00$16.00
You save: $4.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Discussion and Debate in Indian Philosophy - Issues in Vedanta, Mimamsa and Nyaya
Item Code: IDE095
$40.00$32.00
You save: $8.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Who's Who of Teachers and Scholars in Philosophy in India
Item Code: IDH577
$5.50$4.40
You save: $1.10 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now

Testimonials

Very grateful for this service, of making this precious treasure of Haveli Sangeet for ThakurJi so easily in the US. Appreciate the fact that notation is provided.
Leena, USA.
The Bhairava painting I ordered by Sri Kailash Raj is excellent. I have been purchasing from Exotic India for well over a decade and am always beyond delighted with my extraordinary purchases and customer service. Thank you.
Marc, UK
I have been buying from Exotic India for years and am always pleased and excited to receive my packages. Thanks for the quality products.
Delia, USA
As ever, brilliant price and service.
Howard, UK.
The best and fastest service worldwide - I am in Australia and I put in a big order of books (14 items) on a Wednesday; it was sent on Friday and arrived at my doorstep early on Monday morning - amazing! All very securely packed in a very strong cardboard box. I have bought several times from Exotic India and the service is always exceptionally good. THANK YOU and NAMASTE!
Charles (Rudra)
I just wanted to say that this is I think my 3rd (big) order from you, and the last two times I received immaculate service, the books arrived well and it has been a very pleasant experience. Just wanted to say thanks for your efficient service.
Shantala, Belgium
Thank you so much EXOTIC INDIA for the wonderfull packaging!! I received my order today and it was gift wrapped with so much love and taste in a beautiful golden gift wrap and everything was neat and beautifully packed. Also my order came very fast... i am impressed! Besides selling fantastic items, you provide an exceptional customer service and i will surely purchase again from you! I am very glad and happy :) Thank you, Salma
Salma, Canada.
Artwork received today. Very pleased both with the product quality and speed of delivery. Many thanks for your help.
Carl, UK.
I wanted to let you know how happy we are with our framed pieces of Shree Durga and Shree Kali. Thank you and thank your framers for us. By the way, this month we offered a Puja and Yagna to the Ardhanarishwara murti we purchased from you last November. The Brahmin priest, Shree Vivek Godbol, who was visiting LA preformed the rites. He really loved our murti and thought it very paka. I am so happy to have found your site , it is very paka and trustworthy. Plus such great packing and quick shipping. Thanks for your service Vipin, it is a pleasure.
Gina, USA
My marble statue of Durga arrived today in perfect condition, it's such a beautiful statue. Thanks again for giving me a discount on it, I'm always very pleased with the items I order from you. You always have the best quality items.
Charles, Tennessee
TRUSTe
Language:
Currency:
All rights reserved. Copyright 2017 © Exotic India