Subscribe for Newsletters and Discounts
Be the first to receive our thoughtfully written
religious articles and product discounts.
Your interests (Optional)
This will help us make recommendations and send discounts and sale information at times.
By registering, you may receive account related information, our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
.
By subscribing, you will receive our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. All emails will be sent by Exotic India using the email address info@exoticindia.com.

Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
|6
Your Cart (0)
Share our website with your friends.
Email this page to a friend
Books > Hindu > Kumarila Bhatta Tantravarttika (A Commentary on Sabara's Bhasya on the Purvamimamsa Sutras of Jaimini) (Fascicles I-IX) (In Two Volumes)
Displaying 1568 of 7299         Previous  |  NextSubscribe to our newsletter and discounts
Kumarila Bhatta Tantravarttika (A Commentary on Sabara's Bhasya on the Purvamimamsa Sutras of Jaimini) (Fascicles I-IX) (In Two Volumes)
Pages from the book
Kumarila Bhatta Tantravarttika (A Commentary on Sabara's Bhasya on the Purvamimamsa Sutras of Jaimini) (Fascicles I-IX) (In Two Volumes)
Look Inside the Book
Description

From the Jacket

Tantravarttika is the magnum opus of Kumarila Bhatta, a seventh century thinker and greatest exponent of the Purva Mimamsa system. Founder of the Bhatta school of Mimamsa, he was a native of South India. This work is a commentary on a part of Kumarila's commentary on Purvamimamsa Sutra of Jaimini and Sabara-svamin's Bhasya, mainly in prose, running from Adhyaya I, Pada II to the end of Adhyaya III. This is a unique work showing the deep scholarship of the author. Here Kumarila has shown his mastery over other schools of thought as well. His other works are Slokavartika, a commentary on I. 1 of the Purvamimamsa Sutra of Jaimini. This great work was translated for the first time into English by Dr. Ganganatha Jha and published in Bibliotheca Indica Series, of which this is a reprint.

The translator, Dr. Ganganatha Jha. (1871) was a versatile scholar. He was a Professor of Sanskrit in the old Muir Central College Allahabad, then the Principal of the government Sanskrit College, Banaras and then the vice-Chancellor of the Allahabad University for nine years. Though engaged in all these multifarious duties he was able to write more than fifty works on different Indian philosophical systems. In addition to the tantravarttika, he also translated Kumarila's Slokavarttika and Sabara's Bhasya into English. He was the first scholar to write a thesis on 'The Prabhakara School of Purvamimamsa'

Introduction

The Introduction to a book like the Tantra-Vartika is expected to contain (1) an account of the Author and (2) a brief account of the contents of the work. As regards (1), I have secured a contribution from my esteemed friend, Pandit Gopinath Kaviraj of the Sanskrit College, Benares, which is given below. As regards (2), I have nothing very much to add to what I have already said in my work on the Prabhakara School of Purva Mimansa. I have however come across certain criticism upon this latter work, and I shall take the opportunity afforded by this in Introduction to state how far, if at all, I am prepared to modify my earlier opinions in the light of the said criticisms.

Pandit Pashupatinath Shastri has just brought out his book on the Introduction to Purva Mimansa. On page 10 of this book the learned writer demurs to my view that Kumarila has denied the creation of the world by God. He admits that "Kumarila has said that God does neither superintend nor is the cause of this creation, and that the creation or dissolution of the world is impossible." This is enough for my purposes; what was the motive that led Kumarila to deny all this belongs to a sphere of psychological research which is beyond the purview of my somewhat dull intellect.

As regards Prabhakara's view, Pandit Pashupatinath Shastri says: "If we accept this view (that the Upanisads are Arthavada) the Vedanta darshana will be lost to the Prabhakaras. The loss of such a system is not a trifling matter. If it be admitted that one text is not Arthavada, it can be no longer said that other texts of the same class are mere Arthavada."

One is surprised at finding such an opinion coming from a professed student of Purva Mimansa, which teems with Adhikaranas among which, while some passages are regarded as Arthavada, others "of the same class" are not regarded as such.

The writer admits here also that "the Prabhakaras have denied the creation of the world"; but here, as before, he proceeds to examine the motive underlying the denial.

In an important matter like this, writers like Kumarila and Prabhakara, having made a categorical denial, would certainly have supplemented it by an equally categorical affirmation of creation by God if they had held it to be true; and they would not have left their motive to be unraveled by a writer appearing more than 1, 000 years later.

We know that Kumarila and Prabhakara were firm believers in the soul and therefore they have both devoted a section of their works to that subject. If they had been equally firm in their belief in a creator-God, they would certainly have devoted an important section of their work to that important subject also. This they have not done; and their negative view also with regard to the existence of a creator they have brought in only as a side issue. The learned Shastri is at pains to show that these two writers are not atheistic, Nastika. I may be permitted to point out that there is a confusion of thought on this question. In the domain of Sanskrit philosophical literature, the word 'Nastika' is not generally synonymous with 'Atheist.' In fact the common definition of the Nastika that we meet with is that he is one who decries, i.e., does not believe in, the authority of the Vedas;-or in more philosophical works, as one who does not believe in the existence of a soul or a world other than the physical. If we take the word 'Nastika's in these connotations, certainly neither Kumarila nor Prabhakara is a Nastika, because both the them uphold the authority of the Vedas and believe in the existence of soul and of the other world. This disposes of the reference to the Nyayaratnavali, which has declared the Bhatta and the Prabhakara systems to be Astika.

In Chapter II, the writer, towards the end, has drawn a distinction between words conveying their meaning and giving rise to valid cognitions. But in this he has apparently missed the whole point of the theory that every, cognition is self-sufficient in its validity. If the word conveys a meaning, that is, it brings about a cognition, that cognition must be valid per se, and for the sake of validity there need be no dependence upon anything else; so that if according to the author a word has to be dependent, for the sake of validity, upon other words, it comes to the same thing as to say that it does not convey any meaning at all.

As regards the cognition of the soul, if the cognisor is Ahampratyayagamya, it means that he is 'the object of the notion of I'; and I would certainly accept the verdict of the Shastradipika rather than that of its very modern commentary.

Further, we have understood Kumarila's position to be that a knowledge and recognition of the soul is essential for the purpose of the performance of one's duties, and in that sense it is essential in a way to final liberation. But it is not the direct cause of liberation, as has been held by other philosophers. Knowledge is certainly necessary; but only as an accessory. It is in this sense also that knowledge of the soul is subservient to Karma. The writer admits that knowledge alone is not enough to destroy all Karmas and hence lead to liberation. That is exactly the view that I hold as Kumarila's, and I fail to see where I have not paid attention to the context.

As regards Pandit Kuppuswami Shastri's remarks in the paper read by him at the Oriental Conference, I have nothing to say. Until we have actually discovered the works of the various Vrttikaras, we must agree to differ on the subject; but I do feel inclined to accept the conclusions which the learned Pandit has drawn. But this question, as also the question of the relationship between Kumarila and Prabhakara must remain an open one, until the older vrttis have been discovered and also until the work of Prabhakara himself must hold our should in patience and welcome all contributions from such learned colleagues as Pandit Kuppuswami Shastri and Pandit Pashupatinath Shastri.

I cannot let this opportunity pass of acknowledging my obligations to (1) Mahamahopadhyaya Pandit Chitradhara Mishra, with whom I read all the Mimansa that I know, (2) to my fried, Babu Govinda-dasa, of Benares, my life-long 'literary mentor,' and (3) to my patron, the late Maharaja Laksmishvara Singh Bahadur of Darbhanga to whose kindness and loving care I owe what I am, have, and am going to be in the world.

The work has taken long to be completed. This has been due to causes over which no one seems to have had control

 

Contents

 

1 Introduction i
2 Preliminary Essay v
3 List of Commentaries xix
4 Analytical list of contents of the Tantravarttika xxi-clxi
5 English translation of the Text 1-1712
  Adhyaya I 1
  Pada II 1
  Pada Ill 104
  Pada IV 373
  Adhyaya II 465
  Pada I 465
  Pada II 610
  Pada III 805
  Pada IV 890
  Adhyaya III 921
  Pada I 921
  Pada II 1053
  Pada III 1131
  Pada IV 1269
  Pada V 1445
  Pada VI 1505
  PadaVII 1595
  Pada VIII 1661
6 Alphabetical Index 1713-1728

 

Sample Pages

Vol-I

















Vol-II

















Kumarila Bhatta Tantravarttika (A Commentary on Sabara's Bhasya on the Purvamimamsa Sutras of Jaimini) (Fascicles I-IX) (In Two Volumes)

Item Code:
IDJ139
Cover:
Hardcover
Edition:
1998
ISBN:
8176240257
Language:
English
Size:
9.5" X 6.5"
Pages:
1888
Other Details:
Weight of the Book: 2.965 Kg
Price:
$105.00
Discounted:
$78.75   Shipping Free - 4 to 6 days
You Save:
$26.25 (25%)
Look Inside the Book
Add to Wishlist
Send as e-card
Send as free online greeting card
Kumarila Bhatta Tantravarttika (A Commentary on Sabara's Bhasya on the Purvamimamsa Sutras of Jaimini) (Fascicles I-IX) (In Two Volumes)

Verify the characters on the left

From:
Edit     
You will be informed as and when your card is viewed. Please note that your card will be active in the system for 30 days.

Viewed 11219 times since 7th Mar, 2017

From the Jacket

Tantravarttika is the magnum opus of Kumarila Bhatta, a seventh century thinker and greatest exponent of the Purva Mimamsa system. Founder of the Bhatta school of Mimamsa, he was a native of South India. This work is a commentary on a part of Kumarila's commentary on Purvamimamsa Sutra of Jaimini and Sabara-svamin's Bhasya, mainly in prose, running from Adhyaya I, Pada II to the end of Adhyaya III. This is a unique work showing the deep scholarship of the author. Here Kumarila has shown his mastery over other schools of thought as well. His other works are Slokavartika, a commentary on I. 1 of the Purvamimamsa Sutra of Jaimini. This great work was translated for the first time into English by Dr. Ganganatha Jha and published in Bibliotheca Indica Series, of which this is a reprint.

The translator, Dr. Ganganatha Jha. (1871) was a versatile scholar. He was a Professor of Sanskrit in the old Muir Central College Allahabad, then the Principal of the government Sanskrit College, Banaras and then the vice-Chancellor of the Allahabad University for nine years. Though engaged in all these multifarious duties he was able to write more than fifty works on different Indian philosophical systems. In addition to the tantravarttika, he also translated Kumarila's Slokavarttika and Sabara's Bhasya into English. He was the first scholar to write a thesis on 'The Prabhakara School of Purvamimamsa'

Introduction

The Introduction to a book like the Tantra-Vartika is expected to contain (1) an account of the Author and (2) a brief account of the contents of the work. As regards (1), I have secured a contribution from my esteemed friend, Pandit Gopinath Kaviraj of the Sanskrit College, Benares, which is given below. As regards (2), I have nothing very much to add to what I have already said in my work on the Prabhakara School of Purva Mimansa. I have however come across certain criticism upon this latter work, and I shall take the opportunity afforded by this in Introduction to state how far, if at all, I am prepared to modify my earlier opinions in the light of the said criticisms.

Pandit Pashupatinath Shastri has just brought out his book on the Introduction to Purva Mimansa. On page 10 of this book the learned writer demurs to my view that Kumarila has denied the creation of the world by God. He admits that "Kumarila has said that God does neither superintend nor is the cause of this creation, and that the creation or dissolution of the world is impossible." This is enough for my purposes; what was the motive that led Kumarila to deny all this belongs to a sphere of psychological research which is beyond the purview of my somewhat dull intellect.

As regards Prabhakara's view, Pandit Pashupatinath Shastri says: "If we accept this view (that the Upanisads are Arthavada) the Vedanta darshana will be lost to the Prabhakaras. The loss of such a system is not a trifling matter. If it be admitted that one text is not Arthavada, it can be no longer said that other texts of the same class are mere Arthavada."

One is surprised at finding such an opinion coming from a professed student of Purva Mimansa, which teems with Adhikaranas among which, while some passages are regarded as Arthavada, others "of the same class" are not regarded as such.

The writer admits here also that "the Prabhakaras have denied the creation of the world"; but here, as before, he proceeds to examine the motive underlying the denial.

In an important matter like this, writers like Kumarila and Prabhakara, having made a categorical denial, would certainly have supplemented it by an equally categorical affirmation of creation by God if they had held it to be true; and they would not have left their motive to be unraveled by a writer appearing more than 1, 000 years later.

We know that Kumarila and Prabhakara were firm believers in the soul and therefore they have both devoted a section of their works to that subject. If they had been equally firm in their belief in a creator-God, they would certainly have devoted an important section of their work to that important subject also. This they have not done; and their negative view also with regard to the existence of a creator they have brought in only as a side issue. The learned Shastri is at pains to show that these two writers are not atheistic, Nastika. I may be permitted to point out that there is a confusion of thought on this question. In the domain of Sanskrit philosophical literature, the word 'Nastika' is not generally synonymous with 'Atheist.' In fact the common definition of the Nastika that we meet with is that he is one who decries, i.e., does not believe in, the authority of the Vedas;-or in more philosophical works, as one who does not believe in the existence of a soul or a world other than the physical. If we take the word 'Nastika's in these connotations, certainly neither Kumarila nor Prabhakara is a Nastika, because both the them uphold the authority of the Vedas and believe in the existence of soul and of the other world. This disposes of the reference to the Nyayaratnavali, which has declared the Bhatta and the Prabhakara systems to be Astika.

In Chapter II, the writer, towards the end, has drawn a distinction between words conveying their meaning and giving rise to valid cognitions. But in this he has apparently missed the whole point of the theory that every, cognition is self-sufficient in its validity. If the word conveys a meaning, that is, it brings about a cognition, that cognition must be valid per se, and for the sake of validity there need be no dependence upon anything else; so that if according to the author a word has to be dependent, for the sake of validity, upon other words, it comes to the same thing as to say that it does not convey any meaning at all.

As regards the cognition of the soul, if the cognisor is Ahampratyayagamya, it means that he is 'the object of the notion of I'; and I would certainly accept the verdict of the Shastradipika rather than that of its very modern commentary.

Further, we have understood Kumarila's position to be that a knowledge and recognition of the soul is essential for the purpose of the performance of one's duties, and in that sense it is essential in a way to final liberation. But it is not the direct cause of liberation, as has been held by other philosophers. Knowledge is certainly necessary; but only as an accessory. It is in this sense also that knowledge of the soul is subservient to Karma. The writer admits that knowledge alone is not enough to destroy all Karmas and hence lead to liberation. That is exactly the view that I hold as Kumarila's, and I fail to see where I have not paid attention to the context.

As regards Pandit Kuppuswami Shastri's remarks in the paper read by him at the Oriental Conference, I have nothing to say. Until we have actually discovered the works of the various Vrttikaras, we must agree to differ on the subject; but I do feel inclined to accept the conclusions which the learned Pandit has drawn. But this question, as also the question of the relationship between Kumarila and Prabhakara must remain an open one, until the older vrttis have been discovered and also until the work of Prabhakara himself must hold our should in patience and welcome all contributions from such learned colleagues as Pandit Kuppuswami Shastri and Pandit Pashupatinath Shastri.

I cannot let this opportunity pass of acknowledging my obligations to (1) Mahamahopadhyaya Pandit Chitradhara Mishra, with whom I read all the Mimansa that I know, (2) to my fried, Babu Govinda-dasa, of Benares, my life-long 'literary mentor,' and (3) to my patron, the late Maharaja Laksmishvara Singh Bahadur of Darbhanga to whose kindness and loving care I owe what I am, have, and am going to be in the world.

The work has taken long to be completed. This has been due to causes over which no one seems to have had control

 

Contents

 

1 Introduction i
2 Preliminary Essay v
3 List of Commentaries xix
4 Analytical list of contents of the Tantravarttika xxi-clxi
5 English translation of the Text 1-1712
  Adhyaya I 1
  Pada II 1
  Pada Ill 104
  Pada IV 373
  Adhyaya II 465
  Pada I 465
  Pada II 610
  Pada III 805
  Pada IV 890
  Adhyaya III 921
  Pada I 921
  Pada II 1053
  Pada III 1131
  Pada IV 1269
  Pada V 1445
  Pada VI 1505
  PadaVII 1595
  Pada VIII 1661
6 Alphabetical Index 1713-1728

 

Sample Pages

Vol-I

















Vol-II

















Post a Comment
 
Post Review
Post a Query
For privacy concerns, please view our Privacy Policy

Based on your browsing history

Loading... Please wait

Related Items

Slokavarttika (Kumarila Bhatta)
by Ganganatha Jha
Hardcover (Edition: 1985)
The Asiatic Society
Item Code: IDJ457
$35.00$26.25
You save: $8.75 (25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Mimamsa Philosophy and Kumarila Bhatta
Item Code: IDE388
$14.00$10.50
You save: $3.50 (25%)
SOLD
The basic ways of knowing
Item Code: IDD415
$32.50$24.38
You save: $8.12 (25%)
SOLD
Purvamimamsa Citrapatah with Laghunyayasudhatika of Uttamaslokatirtha
Hardcover (Edition: 1993)
Rashtriya Sanskrit Vidyapeetha
Item Code: NZD803
$40.00$30.00
You save: $10.00 (25%)
SOLD
The Arthasamgraha of Laugaksi Bhaskara
Item Code: IDJ551
$25.00$18.75
You save: $6.25 (25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Indian Psychology (Three Volumes)
Item Code: IHE051
$155.00$116.25
You save: $38.75 (25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Indian Philosophy (3 Vols. Set)
Item Code: IDD348
$275.00$206.25
You save: $68.75 (25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Nyayabindu-Purvapaksa-Samksipta (The Prime Facie Arguments Against The Nyayabindu In A Nutshell)
Item Code: NAD863
$20.00$15.00
You save: $5.00 (25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Vakyartha-Matrka of Salikanatha Misra with His Own Vrtti
by R.N.Sharma
Hardcover (Edition: 1987)
Sri Satguru Publications
Item Code: NAH575
$10.00$7.50
You save: $2.50 (25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Verbal Knowledge in Prabhakara Mimasa
by R.N. Sarma
Hardcover (Edition: 1990)
Sri Satguru Publications
Item Code: NAE752
$25.00$18.75
You save: $6.25 (25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Mimamsa and Vedanta Interaction and Continuity
Item Code: IDJ340
$30.00$22.50
You save: $7.50 (25%)
SOLD
Indian Realism
Item Code: IDD416
$29.00$21.75
You save: $7.25 (25%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now

Testimonials

I love your site and although today is my first order, I have been seeing your site for the past several years. Thank you for providing such great art and books to people around the World who can't make it to India as often as we would like.
Rupesh
Heramba Ganapati arrived safely today and was shipped promptly. Another fantastic find from Exotic India with perfect customer service. Thank you. Jai Ganesha Deva
Marc, UK
I ordered Padmapani Statue. I have received my statue. The delivering process was very fast and the statue looks so beautiful. Thank you exoticindia, Mr. Vipin (customer care). I am very satisfied.
Hartono, Indonesia
Very easy to buy, great site! Thanks
Ilda, Brazil
Our Nandi sculpture arrived today and it surpasses all expectations - it is wonderful. We are not only pleasantly surprised by the speed of international delivery but also are extremely grateful for the care of your packaging. Our sculpture needed to travel to an off-lying island of New Zealand but it arrived safely because of how well it had been packaged. Based upon my experience of all aspects of your service, I have no hesitation in recommending Exotic India.
BWM, NZ
Best web site to shop on line.
Suman, USA
Thank you for having such a great website. I have given your site to all the people I get compliments on your merchandise.
Pat, Canada.
Love the website and the breadth of selection. Thanks for assembling such a great collection of art and sculpture.
Richard, USA
Another three books arrived during the last weeks, all of them diligently packed. Excellent reading for the the quieter days at the end of the year. Greetings to Vipin K. and his team.
Walter
Your products are uncommon yet have advanced my knowledge and devotion to Sanatana Dharma. Also, they are reasonably priced and ship quickly. Thank you for all you do.
Gregory, USA
TRUSTe
Language:
Currency:
All rights reserved. Copyright 2017 © Exotic India