Subscribe for Newsletters and Discounts
Be the first to receive our thoughtfully written
religious articles and product discounts.
By registering, you may receive account related information, our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
.
Share
Share our website with your friends.
Email this page to a friend
By subscribing, you will receive our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. All emails will be sent by Exotic India using the email address info@exoticindia.com.

Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
|6
Your Cart (0)
Books > Philosophy > The Philosophy of J. N. Mohanty
Displaying 730 of 2714         Previous  |  NextSubscribe to our newsletter and discounts
The Philosophy of J. N. Mohanty
The Philosophy of J. N. Mohanty
Description

From the Jacket

Jitendranath Mohanty is one of the leading philosophers of the Indian sub-continent. Known equally for his path-breaking contributions in the field of phenomenology, and insightful undertakings in the field of Indian philosophy, particularly Nyaya, Mohanty has striven not only to extend the frontiers of philosophical thought in new directions, but also to build bridges of understanding between the Anglo-American and the European schools of contemporary philosophy.

The essays in the present volume subject his contributions in various fields of philosophy to a searching examination, which is both sympathetic and critical at the same time. Some of the most fundamental and deep-rooted tensions and dilemmas in the field of phenomenology and Indian philosophy are brought to light in the course of the discussion by such well-known authorities as Karl H. Potter, Bimal K. Matilal, William k. Mckenna and R. A. Mall, among others, Mohanty's Reply to many of the criticisms and observations made in the course of these articles will remain of interest to all serious students of phenomenology and Indian philosophy, for a long time to come.

Preface

The volume on the philosophy of Professor J. N. Mohanty was conceived as a part of the exercise to awaken interest in the work of contemporary Indian thinkers in the field of philosophy, to subject their work to a critical scrutiny and to persuade the thinker to creatively respond to this criticism. The enterprise itself was part of a wider concern that for certain reasons, both the past and the present traditions of philosophizing in India had ceased to be matters of living interest to the philosophical community in the country. In fact, there was no philosophical community; there were only individuals who took interest in philosophy, or sometimes phi- losophized on their own. And, though there were a few outstanding individuals, there was no live give-and-take, no feeling of growth, no sense of critical indebtedness to the achievements of the past masters, or of intellectual accountability to future generations of philosophers in India.

It was these feelings that made the Department of Philosophy at Jaipur in the University of Rajasthan undertake a series of activities such as the preparation of Subject and Author Indexes to about twelve important philosophical periodicals published in English in India, the holding of a series of seminars in which contemporary philosophical issues were to be examined in the light of classical Indian philosophy, the establishment of a live dialogue with traditional pandits in the field of philosophy, the attempt at a dif- ferentiated conceptual mapping of the hard .core intellectual terrain in different fields ofknowledge in the Indian tradition, and a critical examination of the philosophical writings of some of the important living thinkers in contemporary India.

The present volume, The Philosophy of J. N. Mohanty, is a part of this last activity which along with others, though initiated earlier at the Department of Philosophy, Rajasthan University, Jaipur, were later taken over and pursued more systematically by the Indian Council of Philosophical Research after its formation in 1981. The earlier seminars in this series were held on the philosophy of Kalidas Bhattacharyya and the philosophy of Nikunja Vihari Banerjee. The volume, arising out of the earlier seminar on the philosophy of Kalidas Bhattacharyya, along with his response to the critical comments and the reformulation of his position in their light, has already been published by the Indian Philosophical Quarterly in its own series of publications in 1986 from Pune. The volume on the philosophy of Nikunja Vihari Bannerjee edited by Margaret Chatterjee has been published by the Indian Council of Philosophical Research in 1990.

Professor Mohanty has made a significant contribution in the field of both phenomenology and Indian philosophy. Yet, it appears from the articles in this volume that his contributions to pheno- menology are less known to his Indian colleagues. Perhaps, his long stay abroad has been responsible for this. Also, as few per- sons in the contemporary philosophical scene in India seem to be engaged in phenomenological enquiry on their own, they may not have been aware of his contributions therein. In any case, the articles of R. A. Mall and William McKenna, we hope, would correct this deficiency to some extent and arouse the interest and curiosity of the Indian philosophical community to his outstanding con- tributions in this field of philosophy.

In the field of Indian philosophy, Protessor Mohanty has persis- tently been pointing out the serious difficulty in understanding it •in terms of the conceptual and categorial mapping in the western philosophical tradition. The discussions and debate on some of these issues in the papers of Karl Potter, B. K. Matilal and J. L. Shaw should prove interesting to any serious student of the subject.

There seems, however, a significant difference in the contributions of Mohanty in the field of phenomenology and those in the field of Indian philosophy, at least as reflected in the papers in this volume. The former seem bold, challenging, innovative, indepen- dent developments in the field of phenomenological studies. The latter are primarily exegetical, interpretive, trying to find what a term or doctrine exactly means-and, interestingly, the dispute is about the interpretation. To ask the question: 'why is it so?', or wonder how a person who can be so innovative in the context of a wes- tern philosophical tradition fail to be so regarding a tradition which presumably is his even in a more intimate manner, is perhaps to raise the most disturbing question with respect to the situation of philosophy in India today. Ultimately, the paradoxical situation seems to derive from the deep fundamental attitudes which are inculcated with respect to these two traditions of philosophizing in the way they are taught in this Country along with the fact that for most persons trained through the present university system in India or the west, the norms of intelligibility are derived from the conceptual structures developed in the western intellectual tradi- tion. That alone may perhaps explain the pathetic sight of such brilliant minds as Mohanty, Matilal and Potter disputing for decades whether prama is knowledge or something else.

The heart of the volume, however, is Mohanty s rejoinder and reply to many of the criticisms and observations made on so many facets of his work. On reading the response, one may wish that he had taken some of the criticisms more seriously and articulated his philosophical position on the issues concerned more clearly. But there can be little doubt in the mind of any serious reader of this volume that here is one of the most original and creative minds in the field of philosophy in India today. Let us hope, more and more people in the world of philosophy, both in India and abroad, take his thought more seriously and respond to it critically and creatively.

CONTENTS
  Preface vii
1 On Mohanty's Conception of Intentionality
Mrinal Kanti Bhadra
1
2 The Noetic and the Noematic
Ramakant Sinari
11
3 Some Reflections of Prof. J. N. Mohanty's Article 'The Given'
Ramesh Chandra
21
4 On Prof. Mohanty's 'On Reference'
R. S. Bhatnagar
27
5 The Concept of Internationality and the Problem of Aesthetic Response
Pabitra Kumar Roy
33
6 Certain Ambiguities and Clarifications in Prof. Mohanty's Gangesa's Theory of Truth
Raghunath Ghosh
45
7 Some comments on Professor Mohanty's View of Reference
N. S. Dravid
55
8 Professor Mohanty on the Concept of Person in Indian Philosophy
Sujata Miri
67
9 Some Reflections on Prof. J. N. Mohanty's Theory of Philosophy
Sanat Kumar Sen
73
10 Mohanty as a Phenomenologist: Hussaerl and Mohanty
Ram Adhar Mall
87
11 Does Indian Epistemology Concern Justified True Belief
Karl H. Potter
121
12 Professor Mohanty on Meaning and Transformation in Indian Philosophy
J. L. Shaw
143
13 Knowledge, Truth and Pramatva
Bimal Krishna Matilal
169
14 Mohanty on the Possibility of Transcendental Philosophy
William R. McKenna
183
15 Recollections and Response
J. N. Mohanty
199
Appendix Some Remarks on Indian theories of Truth
Kaishor Kumar Chakrabarty
219
  List of Publications of J. N. Mohanty 237
  Contributors 247
  Index 249

Sample Pages

















Indian Council of Philosophical Research

The Philosophy of J. N. Mohanty

Item Code:
IDG800
Cover:
Hardcover
Edition:
1991
Publisher:
INDIAN COUNCIL OF PHILOSOPHICAL RESEARCH
ISBN:
8121504958
Language:
English
Size:
8.5" X 5.5"
Pages:
277
Other Details:
Weight of the Book: 425 gms
Price:
$22.50
Discounted:
$16.88   Shipping Free
You Save:
$5.62 (25%)
Add to Wishlist
Send as e-card
Send as free online greeting card
The Philosophy of J. N. Mohanty

Verify the characters on the left

From:
Edit     
You will be informed as and when your card is viewed. Please note that your card will be active in the system for 30 days.

Viewed 4014 times since 27th Dec, 2015

From the Jacket

Jitendranath Mohanty is one of the leading philosophers of the Indian sub-continent. Known equally for his path-breaking contributions in the field of phenomenology, and insightful undertakings in the field of Indian philosophy, particularly Nyaya, Mohanty has striven not only to extend the frontiers of philosophical thought in new directions, but also to build bridges of understanding between the Anglo-American and the European schools of contemporary philosophy.

The essays in the present volume subject his contributions in various fields of philosophy to a searching examination, which is both sympathetic and critical at the same time. Some of the most fundamental and deep-rooted tensions and dilemmas in the field of phenomenology and Indian philosophy are brought to light in the course of the discussion by such well-known authorities as Karl H. Potter, Bimal K. Matilal, William k. Mckenna and R. A. Mall, among others, Mohanty's Reply to many of the criticisms and observations made in the course of these articles will remain of interest to all serious students of phenomenology and Indian philosophy, for a long time to come.

Preface

The volume on the philosophy of Professor J. N. Mohanty was conceived as a part of the exercise to awaken interest in the work of contemporary Indian thinkers in the field of philosophy, to subject their work to a critical scrutiny and to persuade the thinker to creatively respond to this criticism. The enterprise itself was part of a wider concern that for certain reasons, both the past and the present traditions of philosophizing in India had ceased to be matters of living interest to the philosophical community in the country. In fact, there was no philosophical community; there were only individuals who took interest in philosophy, or sometimes phi- losophized on their own. And, though there were a few outstanding individuals, there was no live give-and-take, no feeling of growth, no sense of critical indebtedness to the achievements of the past masters, or of intellectual accountability to future generations of philosophers in India.

It was these feelings that made the Department of Philosophy at Jaipur in the University of Rajasthan undertake a series of activities such as the preparation of Subject and Author Indexes to about twelve important philosophical periodicals published in English in India, the holding of a series of seminars in which contemporary philosophical issues were to be examined in the light of classical Indian philosophy, the establishment of a live dialogue with traditional pandits in the field of philosophy, the attempt at a dif- ferentiated conceptual mapping of the hard .core intellectual terrain in different fields ofknowledge in the Indian tradition, and a critical examination of the philosophical writings of some of the important living thinkers in contemporary India.

The present volume, The Philosophy of J. N. Mohanty, is a part of this last activity which along with others, though initiated earlier at the Department of Philosophy, Rajasthan University, Jaipur, were later taken over and pursued more systematically by the Indian Council of Philosophical Research after its formation in 1981. The earlier seminars in this series were held on the philosophy of Kalidas Bhattacharyya and the philosophy of Nikunja Vihari Banerjee. The volume, arising out of the earlier seminar on the philosophy of Kalidas Bhattacharyya, along with his response to the critical comments and the reformulation of his position in their light, has already been published by the Indian Philosophical Quarterly in its own series of publications in 1986 from Pune. The volume on the philosophy of Nikunja Vihari Bannerjee edited by Margaret Chatterjee has been published by the Indian Council of Philosophical Research in 1990.

Professor Mohanty has made a significant contribution in the field of both phenomenology and Indian philosophy. Yet, it appears from the articles in this volume that his contributions to pheno- menology are less known to his Indian colleagues. Perhaps, his long stay abroad has been responsible for this. Also, as few per- sons in the contemporary philosophical scene in India seem to be engaged in phenomenological enquiry on their own, they may not have been aware of his contributions therein. In any case, the articles of R. A. Mall and William McKenna, we hope, would correct this deficiency to some extent and arouse the interest and curiosity of the Indian philosophical community to his outstanding con- tributions in this field of philosophy.

In the field of Indian philosophy, Protessor Mohanty has persis- tently been pointing out the serious difficulty in understanding it •in terms of the conceptual and categorial mapping in the western philosophical tradition. The discussions and debate on some of these issues in the papers of Karl Potter, B. K. Matilal and J. L. Shaw should prove interesting to any serious student of the subject.

There seems, however, a significant difference in the contributions of Mohanty in the field of phenomenology and those in the field of Indian philosophy, at least as reflected in the papers in this volume. The former seem bold, challenging, innovative, indepen- dent developments in the field of phenomenological studies. The latter are primarily exegetical, interpretive, trying to find what a term or doctrine exactly means-and, interestingly, the dispute is about the interpretation. To ask the question: 'why is it so?', or wonder how a person who can be so innovative in the context of a wes- tern philosophical tradition fail to be so regarding a tradition which presumably is his even in a more intimate manner, is perhaps to raise the most disturbing question with respect to the situation of philosophy in India today. Ultimately, the paradoxical situation seems to derive from the deep fundamental attitudes which are inculcated with respect to these two traditions of philosophizing in the way they are taught in this Country along with the fact that for most persons trained through the present university system in India or the west, the norms of intelligibility are derived from the conceptual structures developed in the western intellectual tradi- tion. That alone may perhaps explain the pathetic sight of such brilliant minds as Mohanty, Matilal and Potter disputing for decades whether prama is knowledge or something else.

The heart of the volume, however, is Mohanty s rejoinder and reply to many of the criticisms and observations made on so many facets of his work. On reading the response, one may wish that he had taken some of the criticisms more seriously and articulated his philosophical position on the issues concerned more clearly. But there can be little doubt in the mind of any serious reader of this volume that here is one of the most original and creative minds in the field of philosophy in India today. Let us hope, more and more people in the world of philosophy, both in India and abroad, take his thought more seriously and respond to it critically and creatively.

CONTENTS
  Preface vii
1 On Mohanty's Conception of Intentionality
Mrinal Kanti Bhadra
1
2 The Noetic and the Noematic
Ramakant Sinari
11
3 Some Reflections of Prof. J. N. Mohanty's Article 'The Given'
Ramesh Chandra
21
4 On Prof. Mohanty's 'On Reference'
R. S. Bhatnagar
27
5 The Concept of Internationality and the Problem of Aesthetic Response
Pabitra Kumar Roy
33
6 Certain Ambiguities and Clarifications in Prof. Mohanty's Gangesa's Theory of Truth
Raghunath Ghosh
45
7 Some comments on Professor Mohanty's View of Reference
N. S. Dravid
55
8 Professor Mohanty on the Concept of Person in Indian Philosophy
Sujata Miri
67
9 Some Reflections on Prof. J. N. Mohanty's Theory of Philosophy
Sanat Kumar Sen
73
10 Mohanty as a Phenomenologist: Hussaerl and Mohanty
Ram Adhar Mall
87
11 Does Indian Epistemology Concern Justified True Belief
Karl H. Potter
121
12 Professor Mohanty on Meaning and Transformation in Indian Philosophy
J. L. Shaw
143
13 Knowledge, Truth and Pramatva
Bimal Krishna Matilal
169
14 Mohanty on the Possibility of Transcendental Philosophy
William R. McKenna
183
15 Recollections and Response
J. N. Mohanty
199
Appendix Some Remarks on Indian theories of Truth
Kaishor Kumar Chakrabarty
219
  List of Publications of J. N. Mohanty 237
  Contributors 247
  Index 249

Sample Pages

















Indian Council of Philosophical Research

Post a Comment
 
Post Review
Post a Query
For privacy concerns, please view our Privacy Policy

Related Items

M. Hiriyanna (The Builders of Indian Philosophy Series)
by T.P. Ramachandran
Hardcover (Edition: 2001)
Munshiram Manoharlal Publishers Pvt. Ltd.
Item Code: IDE606
$35.50$26.62
You save: $8.88 (25%)
T.M.P. Mahadevan (The Builders of Indian Philosophy Series)
by R. Balasubramanian
Hardcover (Edition: 1998)
Munshiram Manoharlal Publishers Pvt. Ltd.
Item Code: IDE607
$30.00$22.50
You save: $7.50 (25%)
Rabindranath Tagore (The Builders of Indian Philosophy Series)
by Pabitrakumar Roy
Hardcover (Edition: 2002)
Munshiram Manoharlal Publishers Pvt. Ltd.
Item Code: IDE603
$30.50$22.88
You save: $7.62 (25%)
T.V. Kapali Sastri (The Builders of Indian Philosophy Series)
by Prema Nandakumar
Hardcover (Edition: 1998)
Munshiram Manoharlal Publishers Pvt. Ltd.
Item Code: IDE600
$25.00$18.75
You save: $6.25 (25%)
Kalidas Bhattacharyya (The Builders of Indian Philosophy Series)
by Debabrata Sinha
Hardcover (Edition: 2003)
Munshiram Manoharlal Publishers Pvt. Ltd.
Item Code: IDE604
$28.00$21.00
You save: $7.00 (25%)
T.R.V. Murti (The Builders of Indian Philosophy Series)
by Harold Coward
Hardcover (Edition: 2003)
Munshiram Manoharlal Publishers Pvt. Ltd.
Item Code: IDE605
$30.00$22.50
You save: $7.50 (25%)
P.T. Raju (The Builders of Indian Philosophy Series)
by K. Srinivas
Hardcover (Edition: 2001)
Munshiram Manoharlal Publishers Pvt. Ltd.
Item Code: IDE601
$28.00$21.00
You save: $7.00 (25%)
Sri Aurobindo (The Builders of Indian Philosophy Series)
by M.P. Pandit
Hardcover (Edition: 1998)
Munshiram Manoharlal Publishers Pvt. Ltd.
Item Code: IDE602
$25.00$18.75
You save: $6.25 (25%)
Builders of Modern India: Govind Ballabh Pant
by Sudhakar Pandey
Paperback (Edition: 1994)
Publications Division, Government of India
Item Code: NAJ026
$10.00$7.50
You save: $2.50 (25%)
The Aesthetic Value in Indian Philosophy
by T.P. Ramachandran
Paperback (Edition: 2004)
Adi Sankara Advaita Research Centre
Item Code: NAG877
$15.00$11.25
You save: $3.75 (25%)
History, Philosophy, Culture (Revisiting Professor G.C. Pande’s Thoughts and Works)
by Sibesh Bhattacharya
Hardcover (Edition: 2010)
Aryan Books International
Item Code: IHL633
$30.00$22.50
You save: $7.50 (25%)
Philosophy and Philosophers
by R.K. DasGupta
Hardcover (Edition: 2008)
Ramakrishna Mission Institute of Culture
Item Code: IDK771
$16.50$12.38
You save: $4.12 (25%)
Perspectives in Philosophy, Religion and Art
Essays in honour of Margaret Chatterjee
by Ed. R. Balasubramanian & V.C. Thomas
Hardcover (Edition: 1993)
INDIAN COUNCIL OF PHILOSOPHICAL RESEARCH
Item Code: IRP60
$16.50$12.38
You save: $4.12 (25%)
An Introduction To The Philosophy of Panchadasi
by Swami Abhedananda
Paperback (Edition: 2005)
Ramakrishna Vedanta Math
Item Code: IDJ282
$6.00$4.50
You save: $1.50 (25%)
Philosophy and Theistic Mysticism of the Alvars
by S.M.S. Chari
Hardcover (Edition: 2009)
Motilal Banarsidass Publishers
Item Code: NAB750
$30.00$22.50
You save: $7.50 (25%)

Testimonials

I have been your customer for many years and everything has always been A++++++++++++ quality.
Delia, USA
I am your customer for many years. I love your products. Thanks for sending high quality products.
Nata, USA
I have been a customer for many years due to the quality products and service.
Mr. Hartley, UK.
Got the package on 9th Nov. I have to say it was one of the excellent packaging I have seen, worth my money I paid. And the books where all in best new conditions as they can be.
Nabahat, Bikaner
Whatever we bought from Exotic India has been wonderful. Excellent transaction,very reasonable price excellent delivery. We bought so many huge statues, clothes, decorative items, jewels etc. Every item was packed with love.
Tom and Roma Florida USA
Namaste. I want to thank you as I have received the statue and I shall always remember the service provided to such good standards.
Dr. B. Saha, UK
I received my Green Tara statue today and it's absolutely lovely, much nicer than I'd hoped--thank you so much for arranging its manufacture for me!
Betsy, California
Parcel received is brilliantly packed by your dispatch team. Excellent collection, beautiful Micro-art work. The items are exactly same as displayed. Hats-off to the collection team. The shiva linga Ring & Garuda pendant were superb. Its pleasure shopping every time. God bless your team with good energy to continue this Real collection work.
Badarinath, India
Jamavar arrived so quickly and is beautiful, thank you!
Caro
Your service is exceptional. I am very pleased with your professionalism.
Shambhu, USA
TRUSTe online privacy certification
Language:
Currency:
All rights reserved. Copyright 2016 © Exotic India