Subscribe for Newsletters and Discounts
Be the first to receive our thoughtfully written
religious articles and product discounts.
Your interests (Optional)
This will help us make recommendations and send discounts and sale information at times.
By registering, you may receive account related information, our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
.
By subscribing, you will receive our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. All emails will be sent by Exotic India using the email address info@exoticindia.com.

Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
|6
Sign In  |  Sign up
Your Cart (0)
Best Deals
Share our website with your friends.
Email this page to a friend
Books > Philosophy > Philosophers > The Epistemology of Dvaita Vedanta (An Old and Rare Book)
Subscribe to our newsletter and discounts
The Epistemology of Dvaita Vedanta (An Old and Rare Book)
Pages from the book
The Epistemology of Dvaita Vedanta (An Old and Rare Book)
Look Inside the Book
Description
Preface

The conception of moksa (liberation), which is the basic, dominant and practical motive of Indian philosophy, has at times overshadowed the logical subtlety, depth and skill the power of analysis, the force of argument, the dialectical acumen and the play of reason in the Indian philosophical systems. This has led to the criticism that Indian philosophy and particularly the Vedanta, is a combination of religious faith and reason, being based primarily on the authority of the Veda-s But in all the schools of Vedanta there are tracts devoted to the treatment of logical problems and school accepts any of its doctrine without the appropriate logical bases.

The logic and the theory of knowledge of Indian systems of philosophy are largely coloured by their metaphysical tenets. There is no logic in the Indian philosophical systems which is not coloured by their metaphysical doctrines. The epistemology of a system is to a great extent dependent on is ontology. Sri Madhva's logic is closely related to his theory of metaphysics and his theology.

Dr. S. K. Mitra of Calutta University has translated an elementary treatise on Madhva's logic, the Pramanacandrika. Dr. R. Nagaraja Sarma has written a running commentary in English on Madhva's Pramanalaksana in his doctoral thesis The Reign of Realism in Indian Philosoph. The present work, based on the Pramanapaddhati of Jayatirtha, is a brief account of the Dvaita theory of knowledge. In the exposition of the theme the comparative method is not adopted in full but I have freely drawn from the other works of Jayatirtha which are commentaries on Madhva's works. In dealing with the logical categories of Madhva, I have compared them with those of the other systems of Indian philosophy.

My main inspiration for the study of Madhva's philosophy was the late Sri Ssatyadhyana Tirtha of Uttaradi Mutt.

My grateful thanks are due to Pandits Yellatur Narasimhachar and Kowligi Yadunathachar who have helped me in the preparation of the work; to the late S. S. Suryanarayana Sastri who taught me the metaphysical and logical approach to Vedanta; to late Professor Hiriyanna whose suggestions helped me in revising the work; to Dr. V. Raghavan for reading the proofs and making valuable suggestions; and to Dr. K. Kunjunni Raja for going through the work. I am also thankful to the Adyar Library for undertaking to publish it.

 

Intrroduction

Sri Madhva's Dvaita Vedanta is a pluralistic, theistic and realistic system. It derives itsphilosophical tenets from the three authoritative prasthana-s or basic texts (the Upanisad-s, the Bhagavadgita and the Vedanta-sutra-s), from the Purana-, and the Mahabharata.

Madhva declares in many of his works that he is the prophet of Lord Visnu, chosen to interpret correctly the sacred texts and refute the misinterpretations foisted thereon by other commentators. On the strength of a hymn in the Rfveda called the balittha-sukta, Varyu is hailed by Madhva as the greatest of souls (jivottama). Vayu is the mediator between God and man. In the Dvaita Vedanta, Vayu occupies the position of the Christ Christianity. It said that Lord Visnu refuses to take anything that has not come through Vayu. He appeared on this planet thrice as the agent of Visnu. The first incarnation (avatara) of Vayu was Hanuman, the second Bhima and the third Madhva.

Found at the end of several works of Madhva in Sarvamulam (SM), ed. Ramacarya and Krsnacarya, Nirnaya Sagar Press, 1892.
There is a traditional verse condensing the nine leading tenets of Madhva's system:

1. Visnu is the Supreme God mentioned in the scriptures. He is the prime import (mahatatparya) of them all. Madhva asserts that every word in the language primarily signifies Visnu and refers only secondarily to other objects. This assumption greatly helps him in harmonizing the import of the scriptures. The Purana-s which praise as the Supreme Deity are set at naught by him. Visnu is the efficient cause (mimitta-karna) of the universe. He presides over creation, preservation and destruction. He is the liberator from, as well as the cause of, the bondage of Samsara (chain of existence). Nescience (avidya), action (karman) and the subtle body (linga-sarira) are the secondary causes of the chain of existence.

2. The external world is affirmed to be ultimately real (satya). It continues to exist at all times. The world process is beginningless and eternal (anadi and nitya).

3. The ultimate reality of the fivefold difference, namely, the difference between God and soul (Isvara and jiva), between soul and (jiva and jiva), between God and matter, between soul and matter and between matter and matter, is accepted.

4. All souls are dependent on God who alone is independent.

5. Among the souls there is gradation. There are three kinds of souls: those that are fit for liberation (muktiyogya-s), those that travel endlessly through the cycle of birth and rebirth (nityasamsarin-s), adn those that are fit to be eternally in hell (tamoyogya-s).

6. Liberation (moksa) is the realization of the soul's innate bliss.

7. Devotion is the means (sadhana) to it. Devotion is that kind of attachment to the Lord which is based on a complete understanding of His supremacy, transcending the love for one's self and possessions and remaining unshaken under all circumstances. Besides devotion, the Lord's desire to protect the devotee is also necessary for liberation.

8. There are three verbal testimony.

9. The existence of God is known only by correct methods of reasoning.

The devotee seeking liberation should first of all act without desire for obtaining possessions. Actions performed without any selfish motive are called nivrtti-karma. The hearing of the scriptures (sravana), reflection (manan), profound meditation (nididhyasana) and adherence to the duties ordained by the scriptures, lead the devotee tot he immediate cognition (aparoksa-jnana) of Visnu.

Madhva has briefly expounded the epistemology of his system in a short work called Pramanalaksana. This work appears to comprise only a few disjoined and broken sentences interspersed with a string of apparently irrelevant quotations from various books, including pasags from a nonextant and untraceable work on logic called Brahmatarka attributed to Badarayana, who, according to Madhva, was an incarnation of Visnu.

There is an elaborate commentary on this work by Jayatirtha who also wrote an independent maniual of the epistemology of Madhva's system, the Pramana-paddhati. It occupies the same place in Dvaita Vedanta as the Manameyodaya in Mimamsa, the Siddhantamuktavali in Nyaya-vaisesika and the Vedantaparibhasa in Advaita.

The present exposition is based entirely on the Pramanapaddhati (PP) and its eight commentaries (published in Dharwar) and treats of various aspects of Madhva's theory of knowledge. Where necessary his criticism of rival theories is discussed. Jayatirtha's Nyayasudha has been consulted for the discussion in certain chapters.

Contents

  Preface ix
  Introduction 1
I. The Concept of Definition 5
II. Pramana-s 13
  The Definition of Pramana 13
  Enumeration of Pramana-s 19
III. Error, Doubt And Dream 30
  Error 30
  Doubt 40
  Dream Cognition 45
IV. Perception 52
V. Inference 57
VI. Defects of Inference 70
  Defects with special reference to the Vulnerable Points in a debate 70
  Futile Objections (Jati) 77
  Fallacies (Hetvabhasa-s) 90
VII. Verbal Testimony 98
VIII. The Problem of Validity 105
  Conclusion 111
Appendix I The Category of Difference in Vedanta 113
Appendix II God in Dvaita Vedanta 118

 

Sample Pages








The Epistemology of Dvaita Vedanta (An Old and Rare Book)

Item Code:
NAM760
Cover:
Hardcover
Edition:
1976
ISBN:
0835674428
Language:
English
Size:
8.5 inch X 5.5 inch
Pages:
130
Other Details:
Weight of the Book: 245 gms
Price:
$25.00   Shipping Free
Look Inside the Book
Notify me when this item is available
Notify me when this item is available
You will be notified when this item is available
Add to Wishlist
Send as e-card
Send as free online greeting card
The Epistemology of Dvaita Vedanta (An Old and Rare Book)

Verify the characters on the left

From:
Edit     
You will be informed as and when your card is viewed. Please note that your card will be active in the system for 30 days.

Viewed 1322 times since 15th Mar, 2017
Preface

The conception of moksa (liberation), which is the basic, dominant and practical motive of Indian philosophy, has at times overshadowed the logical subtlety, depth and skill the power of analysis, the force of argument, the dialectical acumen and the play of reason in the Indian philosophical systems. This has led to the criticism that Indian philosophy and particularly the Vedanta, is a combination of religious faith and reason, being based primarily on the authority of the Veda-s But in all the schools of Vedanta there are tracts devoted to the treatment of logical problems and school accepts any of its doctrine without the appropriate logical bases.

The logic and the theory of knowledge of Indian systems of philosophy are largely coloured by their metaphysical tenets. There is no logic in the Indian philosophical systems which is not coloured by their metaphysical doctrines. The epistemology of a system is to a great extent dependent on is ontology. Sri Madhva's logic is closely related to his theory of metaphysics and his theology.

Dr. S. K. Mitra of Calutta University has translated an elementary treatise on Madhva's logic, the Pramanacandrika. Dr. R. Nagaraja Sarma has written a running commentary in English on Madhva's Pramanalaksana in his doctoral thesis The Reign of Realism in Indian Philosoph. The present work, based on the Pramanapaddhati of Jayatirtha, is a brief account of the Dvaita theory of knowledge. In the exposition of the theme the comparative method is not adopted in full but I have freely drawn from the other works of Jayatirtha which are commentaries on Madhva's works. In dealing with the logical categories of Madhva, I have compared them with those of the other systems of Indian philosophy.

My main inspiration for the study of Madhva's philosophy was the late Sri Ssatyadhyana Tirtha of Uttaradi Mutt.

My grateful thanks are due to Pandits Yellatur Narasimhachar and Kowligi Yadunathachar who have helped me in the preparation of the work; to the late S. S. Suryanarayana Sastri who taught me the metaphysical and logical approach to Vedanta; to late Professor Hiriyanna whose suggestions helped me in revising the work; to Dr. V. Raghavan for reading the proofs and making valuable suggestions; and to Dr. K. Kunjunni Raja for going through the work. I am also thankful to the Adyar Library for undertaking to publish it.

 

Intrroduction

Sri Madhva's Dvaita Vedanta is a pluralistic, theistic and realistic system. It derives itsphilosophical tenets from the three authoritative prasthana-s or basic texts (the Upanisad-s, the Bhagavadgita and the Vedanta-sutra-s), from the Purana-, and the Mahabharata.

Madhva declares in many of his works that he is the prophet of Lord Visnu, chosen to interpret correctly the sacred texts and refute the misinterpretations foisted thereon by other commentators. On the strength of a hymn in the Rfveda called the balittha-sukta, Varyu is hailed by Madhva as the greatest of souls (jivottama). Vayu is the mediator between God and man. In the Dvaita Vedanta, Vayu occupies the position of the Christ Christianity. It said that Lord Visnu refuses to take anything that has not come through Vayu. He appeared on this planet thrice as the agent of Visnu. The first incarnation (avatara) of Vayu was Hanuman, the second Bhima and the third Madhva.

Found at the end of several works of Madhva in Sarvamulam (SM), ed. Ramacarya and Krsnacarya, Nirnaya Sagar Press, 1892.
There is a traditional verse condensing the nine leading tenets of Madhva's system:

1. Visnu is the Supreme God mentioned in the scriptures. He is the prime import (mahatatparya) of them all. Madhva asserts that every word in the language primarily signifies Visnu and refers only secondarily to other objects. This assumption greatly helps him in harmonizing the import of the scriptures. The Purana-s which praise as the Supreme Deity are set at naught by him. Visnu is the efficient cause (mimitta-karna) of the universe. He presides over creation, preservation and destruction. He is the liberator from, as well as the cause of, the bondage of Samsara (chain of existence). Nescience (avidya), action (karman) and the subtle body (linga-sarira) are the secondary causes of the chain of existence.

2. The external world is affirmed to be ultimately real (satya). It continues to exist at all times. The world process is beginningless and eternal (anadi and nitya).

3. The ultimate reality of the fivefold difference, namely, the difference between God and soul (Isvara and jiva), between soul and (jiva and jiva), between God and matter, between soul and matter and between matter and matter, is accepted.

4. All souls are dependent on God who alone is independent.

5. Among the souls there is gradation. There are three kinds of souls: those that are fit for liberation (muktiyogya-s), those that travel endlessly through the cycle of birth and rebirth (nityasamsarin-s), adn those that are fit to be eternally in hell (tamoyogya-s).

6. Liberation (moksa) is the realization of the soul's innate bliss.

7. Devotion is the means (sadhana) to it. Devotion is that kind of attachment to the Lord which is based on a complete understanding of His supremacy, transcending the love for one's self and possessions and remaining unshaken under all circumstances. Besides devotion, the Lord's desire to protect the devotee is also necessary for liberation.

8. There are three verbal testimony.

9. The existence of God is known only by correct methods of reasoning.

The devotee seeking liberation should first of all act without desire for obtaining possessions. Actions performed without any selfish motive are called nivrtti-karma. The hearing of the scriptures (sravana), reflection (manan), profound meditation (nididhyasana) and adherence to the duties ordained by the scriptures, lead the devotee tot he immediate cognition (aparoksa-jnana) of Visnu.

Madhva has briefly expounded the epistemology of his system in a short work called Pramanalaksana. This work appears to comprise only a few disjoined and broken sentences interspersed with a string of apparently irrelevant quotations from various books, including pasags from a nonextant and untraceable work on logic called Brahmatarka attributed to Badarayana, who, according to Madhva, was an incarnation of Visnu.

There is an elaborate commentary on this work by Jayatirtha who also wrote an independent maniual of the epistemology of Madhva's system, the Pramana-paddhati. It occupies the same place in Dvaita Vedanta as the Manameyodaya in Mimamsa, the Siddhantamuktavali in Nyaya-vaisesika and the Vedantaparibhasa in Advaita.

The present exposition is based entirely on the Pramanapaddhati (PP) and its eight commentaries (published in Dharwar) and treats of various aspects of Madhva's theory of knowledge. Where necessary his criticism of rival theories is discussed. Jayatirtha's Nyayasudha has been consulted for the discussion in certain chapters.

Contents

  Preface ix
  Introduction 1
I. The Concept of Definition 5
II. Pramana-s 13
  The Definition of Pramana 13
  Enumeration of Pramana-s 19
III. Error, Doubt And Dream 30
  Error 30
  Doubt 40
  Dream Cognition 45
IV. Perception 52
V. Inference 57
VI. Defects of Inference 70
  Defects with special reference to the Vulnerable Points in a debate 70
  Futile Objections (Jati) 77
  Fallacies (Hetvabhasa-s) 90
VII. Verbal Testimony 98
VIII. The Problem of Validity 105
  Conclusion 111
Appendix I The Category of Difference in Vedanta 113
Appendix II God in Dvaita Vedanta 118

 

Sample Pages








Post a Comment
 
Post Review
Post a Query
For privacy concerns, please view our Privacy Policy
Based on your browsing history
Loading... Please wait

Items Related to The Epistemology of Dvaita Vedanta (An Old and Rare Book) (Philosophy | Books)

Dvaita Vedanta Darsana of Sri Madhvacharya
by K.T. Pandurangi
Hardcover (Edition: 2012)
Rashtriya Sanskrit Sansthan
Item Code: NAF173
$15.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Critical Essays on Vedanta and Veda
Item Code: NAK368
$30.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Theistic Vedanta
Item Code: NAD330
$115.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Systems of Vedanta And Kashmir Saivism (C.A.D. 300?1000)
Item Code: NAC825
$25.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Three Systems of Vedanta
by Swami Harshananda
Paperback (Edition: 2016)
Ramakrishna Math, Bangalore
Item Code: IDJ220
$10.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
A Study of the Vedanta in the Light of Brahmasutras
by Shailaja Bapat
Hardcover (Edition: 2004)
New Bharatiya Book Corporation
Item Code: IDJ467
$42.50
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Fundamentals of Advaita Vedanta
by K. Narain
Hardcover (Edition: 2003)
Indological Research Centre
Item Code: IDE487
$31.50
SOLD
Vedantakalpalatika – A Study
by V. Sisupala Panicker
Hardcover (Edition: 1995)
Sri Satguru Publications
Item Code: IHL221
$20.00
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Testimonials
Kailash Raj’s art, as always, is marvelous. We are so grateful to you for allowing your team to do these special canvases for us. Rarely do we see this caliber of art in modern times. Kailash Ji has taken the Swaminaryan monks’ suggestions to heart and executed each one with accuracy and a spiritual touch.
Sadasivanathaswami, Hawaii
Good selections. and ease of ordering. Thank you
Kris, USA
Thank you for having books on such rare topics as Samudrika Vidya, keep up the good work of finding these treasures and making them available.
Tulsi, USA
Received awesome customer service from Raje. Thank You very much.
Victor, USA
Just wanted to let you know the books arrived on Friday February 22nd. I could not believe how quickly my order arrived, 4 days from India. Wow! Seeing the post mark, touching and smelling the books made me long for your country. Reminded me it is time to visit again. Thank you again.
Patricia, Canada
Thank you for beautiful, devotional pieces.
Ms. Shantida, USA
Received doll safely and gift pack was a pleasant surprise. Keep up the good job.
Vidya, India
Thank you very much. Such a beautiful selection! I am very pleased with my chosen piece. I love just looking at the picture. Praise Mother Kali! I'm excited to see it in person
Michael, USA
Hello! I just wanted to say that I received my statues of Krishna and Shiva Nataraja today, which I have been eagerly awaiting, and they are FANTASTIC! Thank you so much, I am so happy with them and the service you have provided. I am sure I will place more orders in the future!
Nick, USA
Excellent products and efficient delivery.
R. Maharaj, Trinidad and Tobago
Language:
Currency:
All rights reserved. Copyright 2019 © Exotic India