Speaking of Dance: The Indian Critique

Speaking of Dance: The Indian Critique
Description Read Full Description
About the Author: Mandakranta Bose is Director of the Centre for India and South Asia Research at the University of British Columbia, Vancouver, where she also teaches in the Department of Near Eastern, Classical and Religious Studies. She began her Sanskrit studies in Calcutta and continued with them for her doctorate in Oxford. Her research covers the classical performing arts of India, Sanskrit literature, and the representation of women and the arts and literatures of India. Among he...

About the Author:

Mandakranta Bose is Director of the Centre for India and South Asia Research at the University of British Columbia, Vancouver, where she also teaches in the Department of Near Eastern, Classical and Religious Studies. She began her Sanskrit studies in Calcutta and continued with them for her doctorate in Oxford. Her research covers the classical performing arts of India, Sanskrit literature, and the representation of women and the arts and literatures of India. Among her many publications are Movement and Mimesis, (1991), The Dance Vocabulary of Classical India (1995), and an edited volume, Faces of the feminine in Classical, Medieval and Modern India (2000).

About the Book:

Indian classical dance is a 'high art'. In ancient India, it was even venerated as a 'sacred' act. Ever since Bharata wrote his seminal Natyasastra (c. 200 CE), it has been one of the central elements of scholarly discourse, generating a whole host of learned treatises. Mandakranta Bose here takes s close look at this vast Sanskritic textual corpus attempting not only to reconstruct India's two-millennia-long dance tradition, but also to dispel the historical and aesthetic misconceptions woven around it.

With a fresh, critical appraisal of the key concepts surfacing from the Natyasastra of Bharata Muni and some of the other landmark treatises, like Abhinayadarpana, Sangitaratnakara, and Nartanairnaya, the book tries to highlight how these time-honoured writings have contributed to the evolution of classical dancing in India. And, yet more significantly perhaps, the author ventures into a comparatively uncharted terrain seeking to explore the status of performing arts (including dance) in early Jaina tradition. Focussing on the position of dancing in the contemporary cultural life of India, Mandakranta Bose shows how classical dance in India today of tradition and modernity, leading to a vigorous revival of a great heritage, a part of the larger effort towards 'nationalist rediscovery'.

Supporting the text with visual material to correlate the theory and practice of dancing in India, the book offers perceptions that will appeal to everyone involved with performing arts.


IN the first decade of the twenty first century, it is unthinkable that the place of classical dancing as one of the cornerstones of the civilization of India should ever have been questioned. It is recognised today as an aesthetic resource equally for connoisseurs of art and lay spectators both in India and abroad. It is also an art whose antiquity is adduced as a sure proof of India's pre-eminence in the cultural history of humankind. Yet this high status of the dance in India is a relatively recent matter of cultural and political recovery. Venerated as a sacred art in ancient times and energetically cultivated till the beginning of the eighteenth century, dance fell into a decline thereafter. While the ancient traditions of sacred and dramatic dance did not actually die out, they took refuge in temple precincts, shut away from the common view. As far as the general public could see, it was performed by courtesans and street entertainers and for that reason seen as an erotic art that was not only vulgar but solely meant for seduction. Especially under the puritanical eye of British officialdom through the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, dance came to be viewed as a debased form of entertainment associated in the public mind with licentiousness. Judged by the moral and aesthetic canons of an uncomprehending West, Indian dancing seemed to the British and to Indians acculturated into self-abasement yet one more sign of a decadent culture along with erotic temple sculpture and Vaisnava poetry. From that low point in its history to the present high, the dance in India has come a long way indeed.

This progress is not simply the happy result of changing cultural taste but part of a much wider change in the self-perception of Indians and a significant element in the construction of their political identity. The dance traditions of India were demonstrably nursed into rejuvenation by a handful of individuals who were as much attracted by the sheer beauty of dance as motivated by the nationalist need to reclaim India's cultural capital. To project cultural forms like dance as a 'classical' and enduring high art was to assert India's right to cultural parity with the West and by implication to self-determination. The antiquity of dance was a necessary part of the nationalist argument, for it legitimised India as a highly evolved civilization.

Almost a hundred years after the resuscitation of dance in India, the force of that argument remains unabated as a continuing validation of India's eminence. The stigma once attached to dancing has been erased and today dance enjoys both prestige and popularity among varied audiences, and receives government and corporate support. Its progress is marked even more strikingly by the academic attention i~ has begun to receive in recent years. Slight though dance research is as yet, it is a remarkable advance, for when I began my research in the evolution of classical dancing at Oxford forty years ago, my former professors in Calcutta were puzzled that I should have turned away from proper scholarly subjects such as philology or Smrti to a matter of mere entertainment.

The recognition of dance as a worthwhile field of academic study is gratifying for purely scholarly reasons but also on historical and social grounds. From almost the beginning of recorded history in India, the theory and practice of dance, music and drama became central elements of scholarly discourse, engendering an extraordinarily rich array of learned treatises in Sanskrit beginning with the seminal Natyasastra of Bharata Muni, which offer explications of the aesthetic of the dance and systematised descriptions of its technique in the minutest detail It is only fitting that an intellectual tradition born over two thousand years ago should be revived today. At the same time, the dance in India is proving to be the cultural site of one of the most important issues of modern times as a mode of women's self-expression. Although classical Indian dancing is by no means exclusively a feminine art, most of its practitioners have been and continue to be women, so much so that in the dark days of its decline it was condemned as part of women's alluring wiles to enslave men. This sexualisation of dance has led a number of dancers and dance scholars in recent times to view dancing not only as an assertion of the feminine identity but also as an integral part of the enquiry into gender relations in particular and the feminist critique of society in general Given these historical and social implications of dancing, it is necessary to India's contemporary project of self-definition that the history of dance should be accuratey understood on the basis of meticulous research rather than uninformed pride in India's past.

The need for a systematic reconstruction of the dance tradition of India is particularly important to clarify the often confused views of cultural heritage. For instance, the common impression that contemporary classical dances have evolved directly from the Natyasastra turns out to be erroneous when we compare their technical details with the description of dances given in the text. Quite to the contrary, when we follow the evolution of dance styles through the many Sanskrit treatises on dancing written from the time of the NatyaSastra till the beginning of the eighteenth century, we see that in technique as well as aesthetic intent today's dances owe far more to the regional and popular dances that Bharata explicitly left out from his account. The studies in the present volume are attempts to lend precisely the evidentiary authority that may set right such historical and aesthetic misconceptions by means of close examinations of the Sanskritic textual tradition. While this collection is not claimed to offer a full history of the classical dances of India, it does address some key questions in their evolution and the implications of these questions for the theory and practice of the dance in India today.

In addition to serving the historiography of the classical dances of India, these essays will, I hope, help to identify the many research problems and areas that remain to be explored. My own work over the past several decades has opened many such areas to me. The present studies represent my findirgs in them and what they suggest to me both about the principles and the practice of the art. Most of these essays began as lectures or papers at scholarly gatherings in various parts of the world but have evolved into fuller discussions, while some altogether new findings have also been incluied in this collection. These studies do not pretend to say the last word on the nature and evolution of the dance in India, nor on its place in the contemporary world; they are the necessary steps I have been able to take so far .n understanding the renaissance of classical Indian dancing as an aesthetic and social phenomenon.



  Preface v
  Abbreviations x
  Acknowledgements xi
  Note on Illustrations xii
1. Introduction 1
2. Bharata on Dance: The Key Concepts 9
3. Sastra and Prayoga: The Use of Abhinayadarpana 27
4. Defining Dance: Sarngadeva's New Approach 37
5. Nartananirnaya: An Early Textual Source of Kathak 51
6. Nartananirnaya: The Textual Source of Odissi 63
7. The Idea of Anukarana in the Jaina Tradition 71
8. The Lost Natyavidhis of the Jaina Tradition 83
9. The Dance Re-invented: Rabindranath Tagore's Vision 99
  Visuals 117
  Bibliography 133
  Index 137

Sample Pages

Item Code: IDD159 Author: Mandakranta Bose Cover: Hardcover Edition: 2001 Publisher: D. K. Printworld Pvt. Ltd. ISBN: 8124601720 Language: English Size: 9.8" X 7.3" Pages: 96 (B & W Illus: 10, Color Illus: 5) Other Details: Weight of the Book: 575 gms
Price: $40.00
Viewed 10489 times since 20th Jun, 2016
Based on your browsing history
Loading... Please wait

Items Related to Speaking of Dance: The Indian Critique (Performing Arts | Books)

Dance Pe Chance (DVD of Foot-Tapping Dance Numbers from Hindi Films with English Subtitles)
Dance Dance (DVD)
Nataraja Dancing against The Backdrop of OM
Large Size The Dancing Yakshi
Bandha Dance (Gotipua Dancers, Orissa) (DVD Video)
Kuchipudi: Power of Drama, Poetry of Dance (With Booklet Inside) (DVD)
Shobana’s Maya Ravan (Musical Dance Ballet In the Spirit of the Ramayan) (DVD Video)
Dance and Devotion (A Hand Book on Bharatanatyam Dance and Traditional Prayers for Students Pursuing Indian Classical Dance)
Histrionic Expressions in Kuchipudi Dance (Course Syllabi of 4 Years Certificate and 2 Years Diploma in Kuchipudi Dance)
Art of Dancing: Classical and Folk Dances
The Ashta Nayikas (Attendance - The Dance Annual of India 2011-12)
Bharatanatyam Bhakta Guru M. K. Saroja (Guru of Indian Dance Series)
Dance Gestures: Mirror of Expressions (Abhinaya Darpanam)
Mohiniattam: The Dance of The Enchantress
Classical Dances of India
Excellent products and efficient delivery.
R. Maharaj, Trinidad and Tobago
Aloha Vipin, The books arrived today in Hawaii -- so fast! Thank you very much for your efficient service. I'll tell my friends about your company.
Linda, Hawaii
Thank you for all of your continued great service. We love doing business with your company especially because of its amazing selections of books to study. Thank you again.
M. Perry, USA
Kali arrived safely—And She’s amazing! Thank you so much.
D. Grenn, USA
A wonderful Thangka arrived. I am looking forward to trade with your store again.
Hideo Waseda, Japan
Thanks. Finally I could find that wonderful book. I love India , it's Yoga, it's culture. Thanks
Ana, USA
Good to be back! Timeless classics available only here, indeed.
Allison, USA
I am so glad I came across your website! Oceans of Grace.
Aimee, USA
I got the book today, and I appreciate the excellent service. I am 82, and I am trying to learn Sanskrit till I can speak and write well in this superb language.
Dr. Sundararajan
Wonderful service and excellent items. Always sent safely and arrive in good order. Very happy with firm.
Dr. Janice, Australia