Booksतत...

तत्त्वमुक्तावली: Tattva Muktavali (An Old Book)

Description Read Full Description
FOREWORD The present text of Tttva muktavali is by Gauda Purnananda Chakravarti, a disciple of Narayana Bhatta, who was a follower of Madhva school. This work is in verses and is a logical exposition of Dvaita, presenting a very ingenious refutation of the Advaita position. This was edited for the first time by Pandit Becanarama Sarma Tripathi, Professor of Samkhya in the Government Sanskrit College, Benares, and its press copy was prepared during the Principalship of Prof. A.E. Gough. ...

FOREWORD

The present text of Tttva muktavali is by Gauda Purnananda Chakravarti, a disciple of Narayana Bhatta, who was a follower of Madhva school. This work is in verses and is a logical exposition of Dvaita, presenting a very ingenious refutation of the Advaita position. This was edited for the first time by Pandit Becanarama Sarma Tripathi, Professor of Samkhya in the Government Sanskrit College, Benares, and its press copy was prepared during the Principalship of Prof. A.E. Gough.

This short work comprises of 122 verses, all attacking the proposition of Maya. This was translated by Prof. E.B. Cowell into English in the Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society’, Calcutta, volume XV,. n.s. 1883 pp. 138-173. In order to bring out the full relevance of the work, I have decided to publish the translation as well.

INTRODUCTION

Tattva-muktavali or Mayavada satadusani of Gauda Purnananda Chakravartin (c. 17th cent.) is a Prakarana (a sectional treatise) of Madhva Vedanta in 122 verses. This is written in defence of the reality of Difference (Dvaita) and other views of Madhva and in a’ strong refutation of the doctrine of Advaita expressed particularly by Nrsimhasrama in his Bhedadhikkara and Advaitadipika, etc. The other two works ascribed to him as reported by Prof. Aufrecht in the New cat. cat., volume one page 344 are:

1. Tattvabodha-tikii (Samkhya)
2. Yogaviisistha-sara-tika.
3. Satadusaniyamata.

Dr. B.N.K. Sharma in his ‘History of the Dvaita Vedanta literature, ii pp. 235, remarks as hereunder.

“Gauda Pnrnananda Chakravartin (c. 17th cent.) was a native of Bengal (Gauda), He is called ‘Gauda’ Purnananda in the colophon to his work. Nothing is known about his date or life. He describes himself as a disciple of Narayana Bhatta (verse 117). He may, without difficulty, be placed in the 17th century or even later, when the influence of Madhva philosophy was strongest in Bengal.

The Tattvamuktavali, is a very elegent performance, almost unique in the history of Dvaita Literature. There are, of course, some earlier works of this nature, such as the Nyaya- ratnavali of Vadiraja (which is a more erudite work). The burden of the song in the work is that the identity of Jiva and Brahman, claimed by monist is a metaphysical impossibility. It is fraught with serious and terrible consequences on the moral and religious life of man (verses 88, 89, 91-94). Purnananda pleads that ‘Aham Brahmasmi’ should be interpreted only figuratively. He draws a graphic picture ala Vadiraja, of the limitations of man and the infinitude of God and queries with mystic naivete how two beings so widely different in essence could ever be equated with each other (verses 12-17). He observes that there are insurmountable difficulties in the way of a monastic interpretation of Tattvamasi text, as Brahman, in the Advaita Vedanta, is vowedly beyond the sphere of utterance and no laksana can operate in such a case (verses 20-22). He therefore, thinks that text like Aham Brahmasmi should he viewed as having been prescribed for purpose of Upasana (verse 65) and that Tattvamasi should be interpreted as Implying the elision of the genetive case termination: ‘Thou art His (Servant)’. In the illustration of several fruit juices, there is no case for the disappearance of individuality, for, the very fact that the essence resulting from their mixture is able to cure one’s bodily disorders arising from the disturbance of the humors is proof of their persistence in honey (verses 81-83). The two other works attributed to him by Aufrecht (page 344) are not his.”

The text was first edited by Pandita Becana Rama Sarma, Professor of Sankhya in the former Govt. Sanskrit College at Benares. This was published in volume six (1871) of ‘The Pandit’, a monthly journal of the College. An edition, with Bengali tr. by Jagadananda Goswami, Calcutta, 1936 is also repoted by Prof. Cowell. Later the text was edited and translated into English by Professor E. B. Cowell and published in JRAS, n.s. xv, 1883 pp. 138ff. The text varients of the MSS. used by Prof. Cowell in his edition is properly incorporated in this edition for the benefit of the scholars. At places where his English rendering differs from the readings in our edition is due to the emandations as accepted by Prof. Cowell in his edition.




Sample Pages



Item Code: NZF691 Author: गौडपूर्णानन्दचक्रवर्त्ति (Gaudpurnanand Chakravarti) Cover: Paperback Edition: 1992 Publisher: Sampurnanand Sanskrit University Language: Sanskrit Text with English Translation Size: 9.5 inch X 6.5 inch Pages: 54 Other Details: Weight of the Book: 110 gms
Price: $16.00
Shipping Free
Be the first to review this product
Viewed 5496 times since 8th Jun, 2019
Based on your browsing history
Loading... Please wait

Items Related to तत्त्वमुक्तावली: Tattva Muktavali (An... (Philosophy | Books)

प्रमाणलक्षणम: Pramana Lakshanam (A Work on Dvaita Epistemology)
श्रीमत्तात्पर्यचन्द्रिकामण्डनम्: Sastrayonitva Adhikarana According to Dvaita Vedanta
द्वैतवेदान्तविश्वकोश: Encyclopedia of Dvaita Vedanta (First Volume)
द्वैतनिर्णयसिध्दान्त संग्रह: Dvaita Nirnaya Siddhanta Sangraha
प्रमाण वचन संग्रह: Pramana Vachana Samgraha of Shri Ananda Tirtha (Set of 6 Volumes)
तत्त्वाघोत: Tattvodyota of Anandatirtha (Set of 3 Volumes)
गीतातात्पर्यनिर्णय: Gita Tatparya Nirnaya of Sri Anandatirtha (Set of 2 Volumes)
युक्तिमल्लिका: Yukti Mallika (Set of 5 Volumes)
प्रमाणपद्धति: Pramana Paddhati
शाश्वतकोश: A Lexicon of Sanskrit Words
मध्वसिध्दान्तसार: Madhva Siddhanta Sara
पदार्थ संग्रह: Padartha Sangraha
ऋग्भाष्यम्: Commentary on Rigveda by Ananda Tirtha (Set of 2 Volumes)
तात्पर्य चन्द्रिका: Tatparya Chandrika with Three Commentaries (Set of 3 Volumes)
तर्कताण्डवम्: Tarka Tandavam (Set of 3 Volumes)
Testimonials
Fantastic! Thank You for amazing service and fast replies!
Sonia, Sweden
I’ve started receiving many of the books I’ve ordered and every single one of them (thus far) has been fantastic - both the books themselves, and the execution of the shipping. Safe to say I’ll be ordering many more books from your website :)
Hithesh, USA
I have received the book Evolution II.  Thank you so much for all of your assistance in making this book available to me.  You have been so helpful and kind.
Colleen, USA
Thanks Exotic India, I just received a set of two volume books: Brahmasutra Catuhsutri Sankara Bhasyam
I Gede Tunas
You guys are beyond amazing. The books you provide not many places have and I for one am so thankful to have found you.
Lulian, UK
This is my first purchase from Exotic India and its really good to have such store with online buying option. Thanks, looking ahead to purchase many more such exotic product from you.
Probir, UAE
I received the kaftan today via FedEx. Your care in sending the order, packaging and methods, are exquisite. You have dressed my body in comfort and fashion for my constrained quarantine in the several kaftans ordered in the last 6 months. And I gifted my sister with one of the orders. So pleased to have made a connection with you.
EB Cuya FIGG, USA
Thank you for your wonderful service and amazing book selection. We are long time customers and have never been disappointed by your great store. Thank you and we will continue to shop at your store
Michael, USA
I am extremely happy with the two I have already received!
Robert, UK
I have just received the top and it is beautiful 
Parvathi, Malaysia