BooksPhilosophyGangesa'...

Gangesa's Theory of Indeterminate Perception Nirvikalpakavada (Set of 2 Volumes)

Description Read Full Description
Part I Preface In this Part One of Gangesa's Theory of Indeterminate Perception, Nirvikalpakavada, I have tried to analyse and explain the concepts used in Gangesa's text, translated in Part Two. I have also explained some basic concepts of Navya-Nyaya, but I have not attempted to give a comprehensive account of Navya-Nyaya concepts and techniques. In philosophically discussing the Navya-Nyaya theories, I have often included Western theories; but in some special cases, where I...

Part I

Preface

In this Part One of Gangesa's Theory of Indeterminate Perception, Nirvikalpakavada, I have tried to analyse and explain the concepts used in Gangesa's text, translated in Part Two. I have also explained some basic concepts of Navya-Nyaya, but I have not attempted to give a comprehensive account of Navya-Nyaya concepts and techniques. In philosophically discussing the Navya-Nyaya theories, I have often included Western theories; but in some special cases, where I am not aware of Western positions, I have explained rival Indian theories. In these chapters, this book presupposes some acquintance with Indian philosophical theories.

In this work I have incorporated with minor modifications papers already published. In Chapter one, I have included portions of my paper, 'Some features of the technical language of Navya-Nyaya' published in Philosophy East & West (April, 1990), and of 'Some principles and concepts of Navya-Nyaya logic and ontology' from my book, Doubt Belief and Knowledge (Chapter 16), (Indian Council of Philosophical Research, New Delhi 1987). In Chapter Three of this book, I have incorporated portions of Chapters 17 and 18, of that book. In chapter four, I have incorporated portions of my paper in Philosophy East & West. Even though discussions of some of topics are in the context of Indian theories, I have, this book will be useful for general readers of philosophy.

I thank the Indian Council of Philosophical Research, New Delhi, for full financial support for preparation of the manuscript.

CONTENTS

 

  Preface viii
Introduction   ix-x
Chapter One:    
  The Navya-Nyaya theory of cognition 15707
1 Introduction 42461
2 Nature of cognition 42494
3 Duration of cognitive mental states 41760
4 Classification of cognitions 14-15
5 Some ontological remarks 15-18
  A. Collective and abstract terms 15-17
  B. Adjectives 15-18
6 The Navya-Nyaya theory of the self 18-23
7 The Navya-Nyaya concept of the individual 24-25
8 Kinds of perception 25-33
9 Purva-Mimamsa theory of cognition 34-35
10 Analysis of recognition 35-36
11 Navya-Nyaya theory of true cognition 36-39
12 Different forms of determinate cognition 39-43
Chapter Two:    
  Some basic concepts of Navya-Nyaya 44-56
1 Relation 44-45
2 The concept of cause 45-47
3 Theory of causation in Navya-Nyaya 48-50
4 Singular and general causation 50-54
5 Technique of expressing generality 54-56
Chapter Three:    
  Navya-Nyaya theory of inference 57-90
1 Some features of the Navya-Nyaya theory of inference 57-60
2 Navya-Nyaya inference for one's sake 60-63
3 Structure of inference 63-65
4 Navya-Nyaya and Western theories of inference 65-66
5 Expressing Navya-Nyaya inference in English 65-90
  A. Some general observation 65-81
  B. Pervasion 81-83
  (a) Pervasion and generalization 81-83
  (b) Possibility of the psychological process of generalization 83-85
  (i) The Purva-Mimamsa theory 83-83
  (ii) The N-N theory 83-85
  (c) The N-N theory of tarka 85-90
  (d) The Carvaka theory 88-90
Chapter Four:    
  Some term of he technical language of Navya-Nyaya 91-93
1 Introduction 91-93
2 The Navya-Nyaya theory 93-94
3 The Navya-Nyaya technique 94-95
  (i) Abstraction 94-95
  (ii) Determiner-determined 95-95
4 The Concept of limitor 95-108
  (i) Ontological Reasons 100-102
  (ii) Epistemological Reasons 102-104
  (iii) Meaning of 'all' 105-108
  (iv) Meaning of 'one' 108-108
5 Use of limitors in the Navya-Nyaya theory of pervasion 10-114
Chapter Five:    
  Some aspects of the Navya-Nyaya theory of language 115-152
1 Concept of language 115-117
2 Navya-Nyaya theory of language 117-118
3 Sanskrit as the object language 118-121
4 Divine origin of language 121-123
5 Theories of language learning and theories of meaning 123-123
6 Language as a means of communication 123-124
7 Ontology of spoken language 124-126
8 An ontological problem concerning meaning 127-130
9 The Navya-Nyaya theory of meaning 130-131
10 The Navya-Nyaya theory of word-meaning 131-135
11 The import of sentences 135-136
12 cognition of sentence-meaning 136-140
13 Jagadisa's theory of word occurring in a sentence 140
14 Gadadhara's theory of word-meaning 141-144
15 Gadadhara's theory of anaphora 144-152
  Bibliography 152-154

Part II

ISBN :8185636028

About the Book

In this Part Two the text of Nirvikalpakavada section of Gangesa’s Tattvacintamani has been translated and explained with the help of two commentaries, Aloka of Jayadeva Misra and Prakasa of Rucidatta Misra.

About the Author

Sibajiban Bhattacharyya taught philosophy for forty five years in different Universities and Institutes in India and abroad. He has published several books, edited Journals and books in philosophy, and has published innumerable articles, discussion notes, reviews in different Journals, Anthologies, Encyclopaedias, Indian and foreign. Professor Bhattacharyya is now a National Fellow of the Indian Council of Philsophical Research, New Delhi.

Preface

In this Part Two, the text of Nirvikalpakavada is reproduced from Gangesa’s Tattvacintamani (TCM) (Part I) edited by Dr. N.S. Ramanuja Tatacharya. I have excluded Gangesa’s Visesanopalaksanavada section from this book as it forms a separate chapter in Tatacharya’s edition. I have explained Gangesa’s text with the help of two commentaries, Jayadeva Misra’s Aloka published in TCM, edited by Kamakhyanatha Tarkavagisa, and Rucidatta’s Prakasa published in Dr. Tatacharya’s edition. I have given the relevant portions of the texts of the commentaries in an appendix (Notes and References) at the end of the book.

I have found a special difficulty in translating and explaining Gangesa’s text. There are passages where Gangesa is obviously stating the opponent’s position; but there are also passages where it is not clear whether he is stating his own opponent’s position or his own. Moreover, in replies to objections, it is not always clear whether Gangesa is stating his own position, or the position of someone else supporting the Nyaya theory. In such ambiguous passages, I have tried to follow the clarifications given in the commentaries; but it may be that I am mistaken in my reading of the case. I leave it to experts to judge on this point.

There are also many passages in Gangesa’s text which were unclear to me. I must thank Dr. N.S. Ramanuja Tatacharya, who in spite of his heavy schedule of work as Vice-Chancellor of Kendriya Sanskrit Vidyapeetha, Tirupati, was kind enough to remove my doubts with his characteristic clarity and depth of understanding of Navya-Nyaya texts. I only hope that I have presented his views correctly from memory. Without his help the book would have been worse than it is.

I thank Professor Stephen Phillips of the University of Texas at Austin for correcting typographical errors and grammatical mistakes, and for suggesting various improvements.

I also thank Professor K.T. Pandurangi and Dr. D. Prahladachar of Bangalore University for explaining to me some passages of Prakarana-pancika which I have included here.

Contents

 

  Preface  
  Glossary  
  Part Two : Nirvikalpakavadah TEXT, TANSLATION AND EXPLANATION  
1 Gangesa’s theory of two kinds of perception, indeterminate and determinate 1
1 Gangesa’s explication of indeterminate perception 4
1.1 Criticism : No need to postulate indeterminate perception 6
2.1 Gangesa’s argument for qualificative cognition being caused by cognition of a qualifier and its criticism 9
2.1 Gangesa’s reply 16
3.1 Another objection and a proposed reply 21
3.1 Gangesa’s position 25
4.0 An objection to Gangesa’s position 33
5.0 An argument for indeterminate perception and a reply by Mimamsakas in support of Nyaya 35
6.0 Another argument for indeterminate perception and its criticism 39
7.0 Difficulty of defining qualificative cognition 45
7.2 Other definnitions of qualificative cognition examined 48
8.0 Gangesa’s solution 53
8.1 Another objection to infinite regress and Gangesa’s reply 58
8.3 Another objection to indeterminate perception and Gangesa’s refutation 63
8.4 Another objection to Gangesa’s reply 64
8.5 A further objection and its reply 65
8.5 Further explanation of significance of qualifiers 67
9 Concept of qualified object explained 69
9.1 Objection to Gangesa’s theory and reply 70
10 Cognition of negation explained 72
10.1 Objection to Gangesa’s theory and his reply 77
10.1 Further explanation 79
  Notes and References 83
  Bibliography 93

Sample Pages

Vol-1









Vol-2









Item Code: IDH167 Author: Sibajiban Bhattacharyya Cover: Hardcover Edition: 1996 Publisher: Indian Council of Philosophical Research (ICPR) ISBN: Vol.I8185636222
Vol.II8185636028
Language: Sanskrit Text with English Translation Size: 8.5" X 5.5" Pages: 254 Other Details: Weight of the Book: 570 gms
Price: $35.00
Shipping Free
Viewed 7170 times since 27th Dec, 2016
Based on your browsing history
Loading... Please wait

Items Related to Gangesa's Theory of Indeterminate Perception Nirvikalpakavada (Set of... (Philosophy | Books)

Gangesa’s Theory of Truth (Containing The Text of Gangesa’s Pramanya (Jnapti) Vada
Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies - Vol. VI (Indian Philosophical Analysis Nyaya-Vaisesika from Gangesa to Raghunatha Siromani)
ENCYCLOPEDIA OF INDIAN PHILOSOPHIES Volume II The Tradition of Nyaya-Vasesika up to Gangesa
गादाधरी: Gadadhari (A Commentary on Didhiti the Commentary by Sri Raghunatha Siromani on the Tattvacintamani of Sri Gangesa Upadhyaya (Set of 2 Volumes)
Gangesa On The Upadhi, The 'Inferential Undercutting Condition'
Gangesa on Upamana in Indian Epistemology (Faultless to a Fault)
तत्त्वचिन्तामणि: Tattva Chintamani of Gangesa Upadhyaya
Pukstacintamani and Samanyanirukti of Gangesa with Kanadatippani
Epistemology of PerceptionCommentary of Gangesa's Tattvacintamani (Jewel of Reflection on the Truth) Pratyaksa-Khanda The Perception Chapter
Gangesa on Yogarudhi (Containing the Original Text of the Yogarudhivada of the Sabdakhanda of the Tattvacintamani
तत्त्वचिन्तामणिविवेचनम्: Tattva Chintamani Vivechan
Encyclopedia of Indian Philosophies (Set of 20 Books)
Logic and Belief in Indian Philosophy
Manikana (A Navya-Nyaya Manual)
Testimonials
I have always been delighted with your excellent service and variety of items.
James, USA
I've been happy with prior purchases from this site!
Priya, USA
Thank you. You are providing an excellent and unique service.
Thiru, UK
Thank You very much for this wonderful opportunity for helping people to acquire the spiritual treasures of Hinduism at such an affordable price.
Ramakrishna, Australia
I really LOVE you! Wonderful selections, prices and service. Thank you!
Tina, USA
This is to inform you that the shipment of my order has arrived in perfect condition. The actual shipment took only less than two weeks, which is quite good seen the circumstances. I waited with my response until now since the Buddha statue was a present that I handed over just recently. The Medicine Buddha was meant for a lady who is active in the healing business and the statue was just the right thing for her. I downloaded the respective mantras and chants so that she can work with the benefits of the spiritual meanings of the statue and the mantras. She is really delighted and immediately fell in love with the beautiful statue. I am most grateful to you for having provided this wonderful work of art. We both have a strong relationship with Buddhism and know to appreciate the valuable spiritual power of this way of thinking. So thank you very much again and I am sure that I will come back again.
Bernd, Spain
You have the best selection of Hindu religous art and books and excellent service.i AM THANKFUL FOR BOTH.
Michael, USA
I am very happy with your service, and have now added a web page recommending you for those interested in Vedic astrology books: https://www.learnastrologyfree.com/vedicbooks.htm Many blessings to you.
Hank, USA
As usual I love your merchandise!!!
Anthea, USA
You have a fine selection of books on Hindu and Buddhist philosophy.
Walter, USA