Subscribe for Newsletters and Discounts
Be the first to receive our thoughtfully written
religious articles and product discounts.
Your interests (Optional)
This will help us make recommendations and send discounts and sale information at times.
By registering, you may receive account related information, our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
.
By subscribing, you will receive our email newsletters and product updates, no more than twice a month. All emails will be sent by Exotic India using the email address info@exoticindia.com.

Please read our Privacy Policy for details.
|6
Your Cart (0)
Share our website with your friends.
Email this page to a friend
Books > History > Eminent Historians (Their Technology, Their line, Their Fraud)
Displaying 2971 of 4966         Previous  |  NextSubscribe to our newsletter and discounts
Eminent Historians (Their Technology, Their line, Their Fraud)
Eminent Historians (Their Technology, Their line, Their Fraud)
Description

Introduction

 

In June-July 1998, progressives kicked up quite a racket. The government has packed the Indian Council of Historical Research with pro-Ram Mandir historians, they shouted. It has surreptitiously altered the aims and objectives of the Council, they shouted.

 

As is their wont, they had sparked the commotion by giving wind to a concoction.

 

As is their wont too, they were charging others with planning to do in some undefined future what they had themselves been actually doing for decades - that is, write history to a purpose.

 

The commotion led me to look into their record - to look at what they had made of an institution like the Indian Council of Historical Research, and to read the textbooks they had authored.

 

Small scandals turned up too. So accustomed have we become to crores being raked off that the amounts mentioned in this narrative will seem less than the pilfering of pickpockets. That is so in part because our standards have become so lax. And in part because the real crime of these eminences does not lie in the loss they have inflicted in terms of money. It lies in the condition to which they have reduced institutions. It lies in their dereliction - because of which projects that were important for our country have languished. It lies even more in the use to which they have put those institutions.

 

They have used them to have a comfortable time, of course. They have used them to puff up each other's reputations, of course. But the worst of it is that they have used their control of these institutions to pervert public discourse, and thereby derail public policy.

 

They have made India out to have been an empty land, filled by successive invaders. They have made present-day India, and Hinduism even more so, out to be a zoo - an agglomeration of assorted, disparate specimens. No such thing as 'India', just a geographical expression, just a construct of the British; no such than as Hinduism, just a word used by Arabs to describe the assortment they encountered, just an invention of the communalists to impose a uniformity - that has been their stance. For this they have blackened the Hindu period of our history, and, as we shall see, strained to whitewash the Islamic period. They have denounced ancient India's social system as the epitomy of oppression, and made totalitarian ideologies out to be egalitarian and just.

 

They have belittled our ancient culture and exaggerated syncretistic elements which survived and made them out to have been an entire 'culture', the 'composite culture' as they call it. Which culture isn't? And all the while they have taken care to hide the central facts about these common elements in the life of our people: that they had survived in spite of the most strenuous efforts spread over a thousand years of Islamic rulers and the ulema to erase them, that they had survived in spite of the sustained efforts during the last one hundred and fifty years of the missionaries and British rulers to make us forget and shed these elements, that the elements had survived their efforts to instead inflame each section to see its 'identity' and essence in factors which, if internalized, would set it apart. Most of all, these intellectuals and the like have completely diverted public view from the activities in our own day of organizations like the Tabhligi jamaat and the Church which are exerting every nerve, and deploying uncounted resources to get their adherents to discard every practice and belief which they share with their Hindu neighbours.

 

These intellectuals and their patrons have worked a diabolic inversion: the inclusive religion, the pluralist spiritual search of our people and land, they have projected as intolerant, narrow-minded, obscurantist; and the exclusivist, totalitarian, revelatory religions and ideologies - Islam, Christianity, Marxism-Leninism - they have made out to be the epitomes of tolerance, open-mindedness, democracy, secularism!

 

This has been their real crime. It has also been a bit of a feat. For they have been just a few: during the Ayodhya controversy, for instance, every other week a press statement would appear in favour of the stand of the Babri Masjid Action Committee - one week over the names of ' eminent historians', the next over the signatures of ' distinguished social scientists', and the week after that in the name of 'leading intellectuals'! But they would always be the same lot. Always the same small lot: six in one statement, eight in the next; their high was forty-two once. But what commotion they have been able to create, and what mischief.

 

They have been able to do so because of what they were advancing - for instance, the Marxist 'thesis' they were parroting in their textbooks - was in accord with the temper of the times. Because their kinds were in critical positions in professions like journalism and universities. And because the rulers reckoned that to garner votes it would be politic to dress up in progressive plumes; patronizing persons who had taken out a copyright, so to say, on the progressive hue was accordingly useful.

 

Most of all, they were able to work their mischief because of the control they came to acquire over institutions.

 

Times have changed: the committed progressive of yesterday is the unthinking conservative today.

 

The needs of the rulers have changed: who can fool the masses today by nationalizing banks and parading certificates from progressives?

 

The theory in which progressives preened about had been shown decades ago to be without basis. At that time no one listened. But today no one invokes it! For it has floundered on the one test the progressives had said alone mattered: the test of practice. Whatever the theoretical imperfections, whatever the empirical evidence, the one thing that counts is that it has worked in practice - in the Soviet Union, in eastern Europe, in China: that was their argument. And as only those facts about these countries were facts which they certified, the argument could scarcely be countered. Today that very argument works to the opposite effect: whatever the logical coherence you claim for it, whatever scraps of empirical evidence you adduce in its favour, the one thing that counts is that it has failed in practice!

 

So, the fashions are changing, the patronage of rulers is evaporating, their holy books have been repudiated in their Meccas.

 

All that remains is their hold over governmental institutions.

The remedy is twofold. First, enable a multitude of other institutions to come up: for this, a few changes in laws, some marginal incentives for setting up and running foundations, and faith in others - that persons outside the state also are eager to do good by the country - are all we need. Second, loosen the hold over existing institutions of eminences of the kind surveyed here: for this all that is needed is to document what they have made of these institutions.

 

Contents

 

 

Introduction

 

 

The Historians

 

1.

A characteristic concoction

3

2.

Eminent entrepreneurs!

11

3.

How to do it!

27

4.

A fitting tribute

33

5.

When cornered, cry 'Petty', 'Personal', 'Uncivilized'

40

6.

‘... after selling himself in the flesh market'

49

 

Their Line

 

7.

A circular

63

8.

Devices to further the circular

69

9.

'Let us look forward to the positive aspects'

79

10.

Insinuate falsehood, explain away the truth

87

11.

Were all these authors also communalists?

97

12.

The policy of 'broad toleration'!

107

13.

The litmus test

119

14.

Erasure to parity to absolution

137

15.

'Maybe perhaps, probably mostly Therefore'

157

16.

Gavah chust, muddayi sust!

178

 

Context and Consequences

 

17.

The tug of intellectual fashions

199

18.

The appeal of 'The Theory', and the antidote to it

207

19.

Programmed to self-destruct

216

20.

The pattern of consequences

233

21.

The changing balance

250

22.

The insidious, the false

259

23.

A few reasons, a few lessons

342

 

Index

373

 

Acknowledgements

388

 

Eminent Historians (Their Technology, Their line, Their Fraud)

Item Code:
NAI151
Cover:
Paperback
Edition:
2014
ISBN:
9789351365914
Language:
English
Size:
8.5 inch x 5.5 inch
Pages:
400
Other Details:
Weight of the Book: 340 gms
Price:
$25.00
Discounted:
$20.00   Shipping Free
You Save:
$5.00 (20%)
Add to Wishlist
Send as e-card
Send as free online greeting card
Eminent Historians (Their Technology, Their line, Their Fraud)

Verify the characters on the left

From:
Edit     
You will be informed as and when your card is viewed. Please note that your card will be active in the system for 30 days.

Viewed 1504 times since 3rd Sep, 2014

Introduction

 

In June-July 1998, progressives kicked up quite a racket. The government has packed the Indian Council of Historical Research with pro-Ram Mandir historians, they shouted. It has surreptitiously altered the aims and objectives of the Council, they shouted.

 

As is their wont, they had sparked the commotion by giving wind to a concoction.

 

As is their wont too, they were charging others with planning to do in some undefined future what they had themselves been actually doing for decades - that is, write history to a purpose.

 

The commotion led me to look into their record - to look at what they had made of an institution like the Indian Council of Historical Research, and to read the textbooks they had authored.

 

Small scandals turned up too. So accustomed have we become to crores being raked off that the amounts mentioned in this narrative will seem less than the pilfering of pickpockets. That is so in part because our standards have become so lax. And in part because the real crime of these eminences does not lie in the loss they have inflicted in terms of money. It lies in the condition to which they have reduced institutions. It lies in their dereliction - because of which projects that were important for our country have languished. It lies even more in the use to which they have put those institutions.

 

They have used them to have a comfortable time, of course. They have used them to puff up each other's reputations, of course. But the worst of it is that they have used their control of these institutions to pervert public discourse, and thereby derail public policy.

 

They have made India out to have been an empty land, filled by successive invaders. They have made present-day India, and Hinduism even more so, out to be a zoo - an agglomeration of assorted, disparate specimens. No such thing as 'India', just a geographical expression, just a construct of the British; no such than as Hinduism, just a word used by Arabs to describe the assortment they encountered, just an invention of the communalists to impose a uniformity - that has been their stance. For this they have blackened the Hindu period of our history, and, as we shall see, strained to whitewash the Islamic period. They have denounced ancient India's social system as the epitomy of oppression, and made totalitarian ideologies out to be egalitarian and just.

 

They have belittled our ancient culture and exaggerated syncretistic elements which survived and made them out to have been an entire 'culture', the 'composite culture' as they call it. Which culture isn't? And all the while they have taken care to hide the central facts about these common elements in the life of our people: that they had survived in spite of the most strenuous efforts spread over a thousand years of Islamic rulers and the ulema to erase them, that they had survived in spite of the sustained efforts during the last one hundred and fifty years of the missionaries and British rulers to make us forget and shed these elements, that the elements had survived their efforts to instead inflame each section to see its 'identity' and essence in factors which, if internalized, would set it apart. Most of all, these intellectuals and the like have completely diverted public view from the activities in our own day of organizations like the Tabhligi jamaat and the Church which are exerting every nerve, and deploying uncounted resources to get their adherents to discard every practice and belief which they share with their Hindu neighbours.

 

These intellectuals and their patrons have worked a diabolic inversion: the inclusive religion, the pluralist spiritual search of our people and land, they have projected as intolerant, narrow-minded, obscurantist; and the exclusivist, totalitarian, revelatory religions and ideologies - Islam, Christianity, Marxism-Leninism - they have made out to be the epitomes of tolerance, open-mindedness, democracy, secularism!

 

This has been their real crime. It has also been a bit of a feat. For they have been just a few: during the Ayodhya controversy, for instance, every other week a press statement would appear in favour of the stand of the Babri Masjid Action Committee - one week over the names of ' eminent historians', the next over the signatures of ' distinguished social scientists', and the week after that in the name of 'leading intellectuals'! But they would always be the same lot. Always the same small lot: six in one statement, eight in the next; their high was forty-two once. But what commotion they have been able to create, and what mischief.

 

They have been able to do so because of what they were advancing - for instance, the Marxist 'thesis' they were parroting in their textbooks - was in accord with the temper of the times. Because their kinds were in critical positions in professions like journalism and universities. And because the rulers reckoned that to garner votes it would be politic to dress up in progressive plumes; patronizing persons who had taken out a copyright, so to say, on the progressive hue was accordingly useful.

 

Most of all, they were able to work their mischief because of the control they came to acquire over institutions.

 

Times have changed: the committed progressive of yesterday is the unthinking conservative today.

 

The needs of the rulers have changed: who can fool the masses today by nationalizing banks and parading certificates from progressives?

 

The theory in which progressives preened about had been shown decades ago to be without basis. At that time no one listened. But today no one invokes it! For it has floundered on the one test the progressives had said alone mattered: the test of practice. Whatever the theoretical imperfections, whatever the empirical evidence, the one thing that counts is that it has worked in practice - in the Soviet Union, in eastern Europe, in China: that was their argument. And as only those facts about these countries were facts which they certified, the argument could scarcely be countered. Today that very argument works to the opposite effect: whatever the logical coherence you claim for it, whatever scraps of empirical evidence you adduce in its favour, the one thing that counts is that it has failed in practice!

 

So, the fashions are changing, the patronage of rulers is evaporating, their holy books have been repudiated in their Meccas.

 

All that remains is their hold over governmental institutions.

The remedy is twofold. First, enable a multitude of other institutions to come up: for this, a few changes in laws, some marginal incentives for setting up and running foundations, and faith in others - that persons outside the state also are eager to do good by the country - are all we need. Second, loosen the hold over existing institutions of eminences of the kind surveyed here: for this all that is needed is to document what they have made of these institutions.

 

Contents

 

 

Introduction

 

 

The Historians

 

1.

A characteristic concoction

3

2.

Eminent entrepreneurs!

11

3.

How to do it!

27

4.

A fitting tribute

33

5.

When cornered, cry 'Petty', 'Personal', 'Uncivilized'

40

6.

‘... after selling himself in the flesh market'

49

 

Their Line

 

7.

A circular

63

8.

Devices to further the circular

69

9.

'Let us look forward to the positive aspects'

79

10.

Insinuate falsehood, explain away the truth

87

11.

Were all these authors also communalists?

97

12.

The policy of 'broad toleration'!

107

13.

The litmus test

119

14.

Erasure to parity to absolution

137

15.

'Maybe perhaps, probably mostly Therefore'

157

16.

Gavah chust, muddayi sust!

178

 

Context and Consequences

 

17.

The tug of intellectual fashions

199

18.

The appeal of 'The Theory', and the antidote to it

207

19.

Programmed to self-destruct

216

20.

The pattern of consequences

233

21.

The changing balance

250

22.

The insidious, the false

259

23.

A few reasons, a few lessons

342

 

Index

373

 

Acknowledgements

388

 

Post a Comment
 
Post Review
Post a Query
For privacy concerns, please view our Privacy Policy

Related Items

Mohit Sen (An Autobiography)
by Anand Kishore Sahay
Paperback (Edition: 2007)
National Book Trust, India
Item Code: IDK558
$20.00$16.00
You save: $4.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Chatto (The Life and Times of an Indian Anti - Imperialist in Europe)
by Nirode K. Barooah
Hardcover (Edition: 2015)
Oxford University Press
Item Code: NAL608
$50.00$40.00
You save: $10.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Poisoned Bread (Modern Marathi Dalit Literature)
by Arjun Dangle
Paperback (Edition: 2009)
Orient Black Swan
Item Code: NAF979
$37.50$30.00
You save: $7.50 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Redeeming Calcutta (A Portrait of India’s Imperial Capital)
by Steve Raymer
Hardcover (Edition: 2012)
Oxford University Press
Item Code: NAJ099
$100.00$80.00
You save: $20.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
India, Central Asia and Russia (Three Millennia of Contacts)
by D.N. Tripathi
Hardcover (Edition: 2013)
Aryan Books International
Item Code: NAF961
$90.00$72.00
You save: $18.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
In the Name of Democracy JP Movement and the Emergency
by Bipan Chandra
Paperback (Edition: 2003)
Penguin Books
Item Code: IHL274
$27.50$22.00
You save: $5.50 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Buddha’s Not Smiling (Uncovering Corruption at the Heart of Tibetan Buddhism Today)
Item Code: IHE016
$31.00$24.80
You save: $6.20 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Communalism (A Primer)
by Bipan Chandra
Paperback (Edition: 2008)
National Book Trust, India
Item Code: NAF727
$15.00$12.00
You save: $3.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Modern India 1857-1964 (Set of 8 Books)
Paperback (Edition: 2010)
Indira Gandhi National Open University
Item Code: NAH114
$90.00$72.00
You save: $18.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
India’s China War
by Neville Maxwell
Hardcover (Edition: 2013)
Natraj Publishers
Item Code: NAG683
$35.00$28.00
You save: $7.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Swadeshi Movement in Bengal 1903-1908
by Sumit Sarkar
Paperback (Edition: 2013)
Permanent Black
Item Code: NAG087
$35.00$28.00
You save: $7.00 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Cities of Kerala: Actually Small Towns
Deal 40% Off
by Baiju Natarajan
Hardcover (Edition: 2008)
Marg Publications
Item Code: NAK806
$75.00$36.00
You save: $39.00 (40 + 20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Gandhi - A Prophecy
by B.K. Mallik
Hardcover (Edition: 2014)
D. K. Printworld Pvt. Ltd.
Item Code: NAI025
$21.00$16.80
You save: $4.20 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
Rebellion 1857
by P. C. Joshi
Paperback (Edition: 2007)
National Book Trust, India
Item Code: IDK544
$16.50$13.20
You save: $3.30 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now
The Indian Constitution (Cornerstone of a Nation)
by Granville Austin
Paperback (Edition: 2013)
Oxford University Press
Item Code: NAF902
$26.00$20.80
You save: $5.20 (20%)
Add to Cart
Buy Now

Testimonials

Very grateful for this service, of making this precious treasure of Haveli Sangeet for ThakurJi so easily in the US. Appreciate the fact that notation is provided.
Leena, USA.
The Bhairava painting I ordered by Sri Kailash Raj is excellent. I have been purchasing from Exotic India for well over a decade and am always beyond delighted with my extraordinary purchases and customer service. Thank you.
Marc, UK
I have been buying from Exotic India for years and am always pleased and excited to receive my packages. Thanks for the quality products.
Delia, USA
As ever, brilliant price and service.
Howard, UK.
The best and fastest service worldwide - I am in Australia and I put in a big order of books (14 items) on a Wednesday; it was sent on Friday and arrived at my doorstep early on Monday morning - amazing! All very securely packed in a very strong cardboard box. I have bought several times from Exotic India and the service is always exceptionally good. THANK YOU and NAMASTE!
Charles (Rudra)
I just wanted to say that this is I think my 3rd (big) order from you, and the last two times I received immaculate service, the books arrived well and it has been a very pleasant experience. Just wanted to say thanks for your efficient service.
Shantala, Belgium
Thank you so much EXOTIC INDIA for the wonderfull packaging!! I received my order today and it was gift wrapped with so much love and taste in a beautiful golden gift wrap and everything was neat and beautifully packed. Also my order came very fast... i am impressed! Besides selling fantastic items, you provide an exceptional customer service and i will surely purchase again from you! I am very glad and happy :) Thank you, Salma
Salma, Canada.
Artwork received today. Very pleased both with the product quality and speed of delivery. Many thanks for your help.
Carl, UK.
I wanted to let you know how happy we are with our framed pieces of Shree Durga and Shree Kali. Thank you and thank your framers for us. By the way, this month we offered a Puja and Yagna to the Ardhanarishwara murti we purchased from you last November. The Brahmin priest, Shree Vivek Godbol, who was visiting LA preformed the rites. He really loved our murti and thought it very paka. I am so happy to have found your site , it is very paka and trustworthy. Plus such great packing and quick shipping. Thanks for your service Vipin, it is a pleasure.
Gina, USA
My marble statue of Durga arrived today in perfect condition, it's such a beautiful statue. Thanks again for giving me a discount on it, I'm always very pleased with the items I order from you. You always have the best quality items.
Charles, Tennessee
TRUSTe
Language:
Currency:
All rights reserved. Copyright 2017 © Exotic India