Preface
"Frailty, thy name is woman". The line, whoever has shaped it, sounds its note in comparison to the presumed strength of men. But, when it is seen in the Quranic legal perspective one is really caught in a dilemma. The Quran describes man and woman as each others "garment" and "potential" with equitable position before law. It bodies a comprehensive set of rules and guidelines ensuring women a position of honour at home and a place of reverence in the society at large. Yet there is another side of the coin. A study of the human history reveals that many people, at different places in the world at different times, labelled woman as a 'devil', impure-being and a witch'. In many countries, termed as civilized now, she remained till the beginning of the present century on the list of interdicted persons under their respective legal systems. Seen in this perspective the au-thor of the opening line above wins full appreciation. This is, how-ever, clear that in the context of Muslim women the problem is not of the conferment of rights but that of educating them about and the enforcement of their rights. The need, therefore, is that the Muslim women and men must realize that the glorious Islamic laws have fallen into disuse due to their own ignorance and to their own detriment. Allah, through the Quranic message, invites all the people again and again to think and ponder over things.
The closest and the most vital relationship between a man and a woman is developed by marriage. On marriage under Islamic Law, the man (bridegroom) is bound to present a suitable gift out of his property to the woman (bride) with a willing heart showing respect for her right to earn, own and possess property independently and to enjoy an equitable position on the matrimonial dais. This gift is popularly known as mahr. How many Muslim women do actually know the nature and significance of this right and how many of them do really receive this gift property from their husbands are the questions that are gaining importance day by day in view of the "modernization" of laws by most of the societies in the world. The practice around us we know is, if not altogether discouraging, but very poor. The situation invites a thorough investigation and appraisal.
The present study considers the following originating questions regarding the nature, object and working of the institution of mahr in Islamic law:
a) Why this institution has been Divinely ordained and juristically recognized by Islam?
b) b) What is the true nature of mahr? Whether various jurists of Muslim law and the judiciary have ever tried to explore the real nature of mahr or not?
c) c) Does the functioning of the institution of mahr have any impact on the other institutions of life, viz, family and society?
d) d) Does it in any way supplement the laws relating to marriage, divorce, maintenance and inheritance for the purpose of jus-tice? If so, how?
e) e) What is the present state of affairs as regards its enforcement and workability in the existing socio-economic conditions in the Sub-Continent and abroad?
f) f) To what extent has the codification of laws regarding mahr taken place in the Sub-Continent and elsewhere in the world?
g) g) How and to what extent have the customs and common tendencies of the people of different places in the world hindered the working of this egalitarian Islamic institution with its Divinely set goals like gender-justice and fair-treatment of all?
h) While this study examines the above points, the general focus of the thesis has been on finding out the rationale of mahr in the light of the Quran and Hadith. Such an endeavour is highly required in view of the differing juristic assertions about the nature and purpose of mahr. Some have said that mahr is a consideration for marriage while as others have described it as a mark of respect for women. It has, however, been also treated as a stabilizer for marital relations. This thesis puts a gloss on these views with necessary references to the Quranic provisions and ahadith. Moreover, this study helps to assess as to what extent the essence and expected role of mahr has been understood, carried out and its purpose has actually been met with in the Islamic society. Besides, the relevant laws on mahr, at home and abroad, have been assessed to mark the legislative and judicial re-sponses and the emerging trends about its working.
i) Additionally, to understand how and to what extent have the customary practices and other local conditions influenced the working of the institution of mahr in different parts of the world, the study includes, by way of sample, an actual examination of the practices prevalent and usefulness of mahr in Kashmir Valley, (most of the Asian and African regions present a similar view of things). Impact of modern legislations on this institution has also been studied. Lastly, some suggestions have been articulated as to what steps should be taken for the promotion of this healthy institution. The detailed plan of study is as follows:-
j) Chapter-I gives the concept of mahr and explains various unIslamic concepts confused for mahr.
k) Chapter-II has been devoted to the study of the origin and development of the law on mahr with reference to the Quranic directives, practices of the Prophet (S.A.W.) and the later developments.
Chapter-III deals with the subject-matter of mahr and its quantum in the light of ahadith and common usages and practices. Impact of modern legislations on the amount of mahr has also been considered herein.
iv) Chapter-IV is a study of the time and modes of payment of mahr.
v) Chapter-V enumerates the situations when mahr is not payable to the wife. With this the validity and effects of the relinquishment of mahr by the wife have also been discussed.
vi) Chapter-VI incorporates the principles of Islamic law and a de-tailed account of judicial precedents about the nature and scope of the widowed women's claim to mahr especially the "widow's right of retention".
vii) Chapter-VII is an endeavour to determine the extent of the entitlement of the divorced women to mahr in cases of extrajudicial as well as judicial divorces. Differences and the inter-relationships between mata', mahr and nafaqah have also been high-lighted.
viii) Chapter VIII gives a review of the statutory laws related to mahr in Muslim countries with reference to the relevant classical law.
In the concluding chapter the impressions from the various findings in this study have been stated and some suggestions have accordingly been articulated to make the institution of mahr useful for the Muslim society in general and the Muslim women in particular. As regards methodology, this study is primarily based on funda-mental sources of Islamic, law, viz. The Quran, Hadith and Juristic works in English, Urdu and Arabic languages. Journals, books and the reports have been used for assessing the present present legislative and judicial trends in India and Muslim countries. Important Privy Council, Supreme Court and High Court decisions on the subject have been analyzed to examine, identify and spell out the mis-conceptions and inconsistencies that have crept in into the understanding of the institution of mahr. For studying the working and usefulness of the institution of mahr in Kashmir Valley relevant statutes and local digests have been consulted. However, mainly the reliance has been placed on the results of interviews and questionnaires.
This work, on which the University of Kashmir awarded me a doctoral degree, was initially taken in hand with the generous help of Professor Tahir Mahmood, Dean, Faculty of Law, Delhi University, who guided me in the selection of the topic and preparation of the basic plan of study. Profoundly, I record the gratitude, I owe to him for his meticulous guiding dictates and kind treatment. His analytical approach has been a source of inspiration for me.
Introduction
Chapter - I 1. Meaning of Mahr: an etymological survey
Islam ordains a 'gift spontaneous', popularly known as mahr, to be given by the husband to the wife merely because marriage has taken place between the two. It has a solid Quranic base confirmed by the Sunnah of the Prophet (S.A.W.). But there exists a great deal of conflict and confusion in various writings about mahr which seem to fail in giving a clear understanding of its concept, social significance and the rationale behind its legal enforceability. In this situation a macro-level etymological survey of the expression mahr is most requisite. Without such a survey it would be impossible to find a basis for marking the magnitude and measuring the parameters of this Islamic Institution.
In its origin the expression mahr is of multiple usage and con-notation. Mahr as noun with Arabic origin stands for what becomes due as a gift by the husband to the wife on marriage. Mahur (pl. of mahr) is also used for 'marriage-portion' or a gift to the wife because of the fact of marriage¹
Francis Johnson describes mahr as follows:
Mahr (v.n. of) indicates contracting; fixing of mahr; paying of mahr or making settlement on wife, and excelling in art or profession. It also means 'going on the right way', e.g., 'Lam taatah hazai amral maharatah you have not gone the right way in this matter.2.
In its broader perspective mahr includes:
i) something lovable, or things having reference to love as a bone in the upper part of the breast, joints of the breast; or gristles of the ribs; or something presentable as a gift like a pearl; and
ii) doing of something in the right way and with skill.
Hindu (954)
Agriculture (137)
Ancient (1141)
Archaeology (845)
Architecture (580)
Art & Culture (954)
Biography (753)
Buddhist (547)
Cookery (173)
Emperor & Queen (594)
Islam (315)
Jainism (345)
Literary (886)
Mahatma Gandhi (397)
Send as free online greeting card
Email a Friend
Visual Search
Manage Wishlist